P5 functions like a cartel. Cartels and monopolies are the bane of the free

Sign up, and you can customize which countdowns you see. Sign up

Report problem with this ad

Sep 15, 2014
5:46:08pm

Mathlete

P5 functions like a cartel. Cartels and monopolies are the bane of the free

market.

Report problem with this ad

Mathlete

Previous username: TexTechCoug
Bio page: Mathlete
Joined: Jun 4, 2004
Last login: Nov 19, 2023
Total posts: 16,675 (840 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

What I don't get, is if the reason to go to a 4 game playoff is to make the

delbert

9/15/14 4:55pm

It should be the best 4 teams. It shouldn't matter what conference they're in.

OpusX

9/15/14 5:05pm

If you're not the best team in your conference then how can you be the best team

BYUflynn

9/15/14 5:54pm

Maybe the 2nd best team in a conference is also 2nd best in the country

OpusX

9/15/14 7:14pm

You are Auburn. You lose by 3 points on the road to Alabama.

9/15/14 10:27pm

No they shouldn't

9/15/14 10:36pm

Let me rephrase: they should be in consideration.

9/15/14 11:10pm

I never think that two teams from the same conference

9/16/14 12:32am

I agree in principle, but conferences don't play round robins anymore.

9/16/14 6:17am

Sadly, with the playoff they will feel more entitled to

9/16/14 11:04am

Very true. I like 4 better. 8 is ideal for me.

9/16/14 10:09pm

It's possible for an NFL team to win the Super Bowl without winning their

workindev

9/15/14 5:06pm

I would agree with this if college football was set up the same way as the NFL

delbert

9/15/14 5:21pm

Apples and Oranges

CougBlu

9/15/14 5:27pm

RE: Apples and Oranges

gwill

9/15/14 5:51pm

RE: Apples and Oranges

CougBlu

9/15/14 6:08pm

It should be the 5 major conf. champions plus 3 others

cocktosten

9/15/14 5:07pm

This is the right answer. if only.

delbert

9/15/14 5:12pm

This was decided upon during the negotiations between the P5s.

9/15/14 5:16pm

I recognize everyone signed off on it, I am just saying I think it would

delbert

9/15/14 5:23pm

Agree. But as ecp mentions below, it' s about money and power.

9/15/14 5:34pm

It's all about money and control.

ecp

9/15/14 5:21pm

I agree.

delbert

9/15/14 5:23pm

It's funny to see all the shrinking capitalists when it comes to football

OpusX

9/15/14 5:39pm

P5 functions like a cartel. Cartels and monopolies are the bane of the free

Mathlete

9/15/14 5:46pm

We invented Cartels.

OpusX

9/15/14 7:20pm

Because the 2nd best SEC team is often the 2nd best team in the country.

DoseOfReality

9/15/14 5:49pm

So when LSU and Bamma played in the BCS Championship Game

9/15/14 6:09pm

No system will be perfect but reality is that two of four could be from same

SwampCougar

9/15/14 6:18pm

I disagree. In Basketball rematches are fine because

9/15/14 6:25pm

Slightly better than the 6-3 reg season offensive juggernaut battle

SwampCougar

9/15/14 6:31pm

Also, We just need all SEC teams to have at least 2 losses which is possible

SwampCougar

9/15/14 6:32pm

True

9/15/14 6:43pm

The committee has its directive

wapiti

9/15/14 6:23pm

The top two teems in the NFL may be in the same conference

delbert

9/15/14 9:37pm

And the keyword is "think"

9/15/14 10:07pm

because they want, theoretically, the BEST teams, not conference champions.

Real Men Wear Blue

9/15/14 7:34pm

Condi Rice will keep things straight and ethical.

Rocketman

9/15/14 8:06pm

You haven't realized by now that college football is all about the SEC?

slatecoug

9/15/14 10:27pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad