No. I would contend there's a distinction.

Sep 15, 2014
9:50:35pm

titlecoug

Corporal punishment as discipline for children is more engrained in our culture than this type of anger and disrespect for women.

Like I said, both are wrong so I think it's a moot point anyway.

Report problem with this ad

titlecoug

Bio page: titlecoug
Joined: Dec 7, 2011
Last login: Apr 23, 2024
Total posts: 13,445 (4,975 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

POLL: Which is worse? Ray Rice, Adrian Peterson:

cougarblue

9/15/14 9:42pm

son(s)

billyrust

9/15/14 9:43pm

Based off the information that we have, Rice's situation was worse. If there

Duke Silver

9/15/14 9:44pm

I go with AP. A 4 year old is more defenseless than a grown woman IMO

billyrust

9/15/14 9:45pm

On the other hand, people die from blows to the head...

BarraCouga

9/15/14 9:50pm

And AP's own son died from physical abuse...

billyrust

9/15/14 9:52pm

Guessing it wasn't from a switch to the butt...just a hunch.

BarraCouga

9/15/14 9:56pm

Here's the difference in my mind.

Duke Silver

9/15/14 10:03pm

Just to make things clear, AP had nothing to do with his sons death.

So it goes...

9/15/14 10:21pm

I know. And Ray Rice didn't kill his wife/fiance either

billyrust

9/15/14 10:28pm

Where is garyfan?

YSMACK

9/15/14 9:46pm

Adrian Peterson was wrong. He needs to change how he disciplines his kids

titlecoug

9/15/14 9:46pm

Could you not say he (Rice) was "raised" that way as well?

billyrust

9/15/14 9:47pm

You think he was expressly taught that it was appropriate to knock a woman out?

YSMACK

9/15/14 9:49pm

Taught by example, maybe...

billyrust

9/15/14 9:51pm

Then that by itself is something of a distinction.

YSMACK

9/16/14 8:04am

No. I would contend there's a distinction.

titlecoug

9/15/14 9:50pm

"Misguided" is quite the value statement

cougarblue

9/15/14 9:50pm

Is someone slices their kid's privates in his punishment it's misguided.

titlecoug

9/15/14 9:53pm

Go to timeout

cougarblue

9/15/14 9:58pm

ah, the beauty of relativism...everything has a line, like it or not.

Scooter

9/16/14 6:31am

Really hard for me to make a judgment on Peterson

hansel

9/15/14 9:54pm

If we believe Peterson, he was "just disciplining."

garyfan

9/15/14 9:58pm

Not even the DA is accusing him of more than over-the-top discipline, right?

The Shazad

9/15/14 10:03pm

Anyone who bruises their kid and breaks the skin is not disciplining. They are

CDV

9/15/14 9:59pm

RE: Anyone who bruises their kid and breaks the skin is not disciplining. They

BengalCougar

9/15/14 10:01pm

my dad beat me with a belt till my butt bled. did I ever tell my mom to shutup

tebowned

9/15/14 10:43pm

It doesn't matter if your behavior changed. What your dad did

CDV

9/16/14 8:02am

Society never accepted whipping with a belt until it bled.

garyfan

9/16/14 8:36am

I agree. I am just arguing that even if it did, that still doesn't make it

CDV

9/16/14 9:11am

Agreed.

garyfan

9/16/14 10:12am

I totally agree.

YSMACK

9/15/14 10:01pm

This is why I think AP's is worse

Remigius

9/15/14 10:06pm

Please tell me where people have said they are ok with that. There is...

BengalCougar

9/15/14 10:09pm

That is what hansel said

Remigius

9/15/14 10:12pm

No it isn't, he said it was a different situation to him. And he also said...

BengalCougar

9/15/14 10:15pm

So where's that line? Is it child abuse for a mother to spank

hansel

9/15/14 10:14pm

<< Deleted >>

YSMACK

9/15/14 10:15pm

It wasn't just on the legs and waist, there are reports that the child's scrotum

CDV

9/16/14 8:28am

Doesn't matter. Both are wrong and have no place in society.

CrackerJack

9/15/14 10:04pm

This is the correct answer. And why this poll is flawed.

garyfan

9/15/14 10:10pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad