I thought it had to do with the "kicking area"

Sep 22, 2014
5:14:56pm

lawboy

And if the defender hit the kicker while in that area, it's roughing. I dunno, it's a liberalized rule, so up to interpretation. Ref gets to determine intent, which is sort of strange.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Penalty_%28gridiron_football%29

Report problem with this ad

lawboy

Previous username: LawPunk
New username: Turnpike Lane
Bio page: lawboy
Joined: Dec 14, 2004
Last login: Jan 6, 2015
Total posts: 0 (0 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

To the guy who sat behind me and whined and moaned about every little thing BYU

darkcoug

9/22/14 5:00pm

I don't think they can hear you

DapperDan

9/22/14 5:02pm

They might be able to.

jdub

9/22/14 5:10pm

Lol.

MarylandFan

9/22/14 9:22pm

<< Deleted >>

Abe Froman

9/22/14 5:02pm

Gotta love when people who know nothing about sports comment on every play.

Duke Silver

9/22/14 5:02pm

You mean all the people who complain about why BYU runs up the middle so often?

lawboy

9/22/14 5:05pm

Is that supposed to be directed at me?

Duke Silver

9/22/14 5:15pm

Not really. Do you do that?

lawboy

9/22/14 5:16pm

Nope. That's why I was confused. But yes, people like that.

Duke Silver

9/22/14 5:20pm

he heard me. he turned and looked

johnnycarson

9/22/14 5:04pm

Did the guy whine about running into the kicker vs. roughing the kicker?

UneducatedFan

9/22/14 5:04pm

hey what is the board consensus on that? roughing or running into?

johnnycarson

9/22/14 5:05pm

He barely brushed him. I thought it was roughing real time. Good call.

dave

9/22/14 7:30pm

I thought if the leg was extended, it's roughing?

lawboy

9/22/14 5:05pm

I thought it had something to do with plant leg vs. kicking leg

UneducatedFan

9/22/14 5:09pm

I thought it had to do with the "kicking area"

lawboy

9/22/14 5:14pm

Yeah I have no idea. Probably a huge "intent" grey area.

UneducatedFan

9/22/14 5:17pm

I have definately heard that if the leg is extended for a kick

PolarisPrime

9/22/14 11:48pm

I think at least half the stadium thought it was roughing

jdub

9/22/14 5:07pm

I did too at first until I saw the replay. Arellano sold it really well.

UneducatedFan

9/22/14 5:10pm

yeah, that's what the guy behind me said.

jdub

9/22/14 5:11pm

As good as Arellano is at kicking. He's also very good at making sure contact is

UneducatedFan

9/22/14 5:14pm

yep, I agree

jdub

9/22/14 5:22pm

My brother started booing when we ran a draw on 3rd and 27

CougarBacker

9/22/14 5:14pm

I think its lame that your brother boo'd on 3rd and 27.

nslcougar

9/22/14 6:42pm

Booing that call was lame but there are

jre85

9/22/14 7:08pm

Oh I totally agree that booing that call is lame, but I also think it's lame

CougarBacker

9/22/14 8:57pm

You dont think booing is degrading others?

PolarisPrime

9/22/14 11:45pm

Absolutely not! Who is he degrading? Robert Anae? pfft Lighten up

CougarBacker

9/23/14 11:15am

I didn't like that play call...

LDTemplar

9/23/14 10:17pm

i think that's a grest point. some people there and here for that matter

cougarmanguy

9/22/14 5:07pm

So you sit in front of a fellow Cougarboard member?

WJCougar

9/22/14 5:24pm

This is why I don't have season tickets... And when I do go, I have headphones

shakavaka

9/22/14 6:48pm

I used to use headphones

LDTemplar

9/23/14 10:27pm

It could have been me. I have no patience during the games. Then afterwards

Shimmy

9/22/14 6:56pm

There seems to be at least 1 of "that guy" in every section.

jedvik

9/22/14 7:43pm

Or a step closer to the edge?

Born2Fish

9/22/14 8:38pm

sorry I'll try to keep it under control this time

jkccoug

9/22/14 9:16pm

That was me. But I was in my man cave at home.

6th-Kamikaze-mission

9/22/14 11:00pm

Where were you sitting?...sounds like my cousin. cant stand him sometimes.

CougarCrazyfromAZ

9/22/14 11:04pm

You must be sitting where I was last year.

Posting on CougarBoard