I know what he was on scout, obviously.

I don't care what you think is debatable. Obviously it's all debatable. It's all a guess. Just like some 4 stars might not deserve it, plenty of 3 stars might, so what's your point? It goes both ways. All i was doing was adding more to the list. That's all. Your (our) opinion on what is "legit 4 star" or not doesn't matter. For as many 4 star guys that you think aren't deserving of it, i could probably go match every one with a 3 star who i think is.

This isn't about who should and shouldn't be listed in those spots, especially on the claim that their star being debatable or not comes AFTER we've seen what they've been doing in college... Well duh.

Btw, Blackmon was very high out of HS and Kurtz had half of the country after him (not literally). Plenty of JC guys are deserving of good rankings and plenty are there for reasons other than their talent level.