More Evidence Recruiting Rankings are worthless

Report problem with this ad

Nov 21, 2014
11:17:10am

CougarinOZ

Report problem with this ad

CougarinOZ

Previous username: Nothingtoadd
Bio page: CougarinOZ
Joined: Sep 11, 2014
Last login: Aug 30, 2019
Total posts: 1,467 (2 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

2015 Recruiting Class Average Star Ratings: BYU 2.92, Utah 2.78

FiveTen-BuckEighty

11/21/14 11:15am

Scout or Rivals? Rivals seems to eval better based upon past ratings.

lawboy

11/21/14 11:16am

Those are the Scout numbers

wcj99

11/21/14 1:46pm

More Evidence Recruiting Rankings are worthless

CougarinOZ

11/21/14 11:17am

Well.....BYU typically does outrecruit Utah in the rankings

TNT

11/21/14 11:17am

It's clear Utah has better players, not talent

teancum

11/21/14 11:36am

Or it could just mean that we have had close games

PolarisPrime

11/21/14 12:10pm

like 54-10?

teancum

11/21/14 12:20pm

Wow - way to find a single game to "prove" your point.

PolarisPrime

11/21/14 12:32pm

better stats....lol

Utesplease

11/21/14 12:51pm

Your right... Utah won because of their sheer awesomeness.

PolarisPrime

11/21/14 1:01pm

Total yards and 1st downs =/= better stats

Utesplease

11/21/14 1:03pm

Wow -is that ever spin to make yourself feel better

PolarisPrime

11/21/14 1:33pm

How far you move the ball each time you snap it is far more valuable

Utesplease

11/21/14 1:37pm

Uhhh...

PolarisPrime

11/21/14 1:58pm

show me an advanced stat that uses total yards

Utesplease

11/21/14 2:00pm

Since you edited your post I need to edit mine

PolarisPrime

11/21/14 2:02pm

In BYU's favor or even? Uh, no.

Utesplease

11/21/14 4:30pm

You're both wrong. The most important stat is...

Frenemy59

11/21/14 4:36pm

Forst off

PolarisPrime

11/21/14 10:05pm

Telling you to take it like a man is not being

Frenemy59

11/21/14 10:18pm

Yes... It is.

PolarisPrime

11/22/14 8:06pm

Yeah! Moral victories!!! One stat matters, scoreboard.

slowhiteguy

11/21/14 12:53pm

Without a doubt score is the most important stat

PolarisPrime

11/21/14 1:00pm

As a stats guy:

teancum

11/21/14 12:59pm

One thing that I have noticed in looking at the records

PolarisPrime

11/21/14 1:06pm

Put down the cool aid. Seriously, you are the master of spin.

Jkampana

11/21/14 1:08pm

Better stats and still getting the L's? Yeah, that IS bad coaching.

BYUisLife

11/21/14 1:15pm

That is an opinion based on nothing.

PolarisPrime

11/21/14 1:23pm

It is based on something. It is based on the fact that we had better stats

BYUisLife

11/21/14 1:38pm

How did we shoot ourselves in the foot - that was related to caoching?

PolarisPrime

11/21/14 1:58pm

Penalties, poor play, turnovers. Mental mistakes happen over and over again

BYUisLife

11/21/14 2:03pm

Saying this...

PolarisPrime

11/21/14 2:14pm

The sentence before the "never has never will" sentence was about Bronco

BYUisLife

11/21/14 2:31pm

Every one of your points has an easy and more reasonable response

PolarisPrime

11/21/14 2:35pm

No you can't. Those guys have had results. Bronco has not.

BYUisLife

11/21/14 2:41pm

Or....every valid "fire Bronco" point is ignored by the remaining few who

unctoothman

11/21/14 3:10pm

Very true. The longer BYU ignores the problem, the harder it will be to build

BYUisLife

11/21/14 3:43pm

Didnt have better stats. See post above

Utesplease

11/21/14 1:23pm

Good Grief. And how many BYU players in the NFL?

crookedUTE

11/21/14 5:03pm

Lies!!!

crookedUTE

11/21/14 4:36pm

When utah state has more success getting players in the NFL with lesser recruits

catawag

11/21/14 11:18am

Holy crap i am so tired of hearing this

Ragid1

11/21/14 2:28pm

Says the man that spells College with an "A". Do you like to collage?

Moneycounter

11/21/14 2:43pm

swipe has failed me again

Ragid1

11/21/14 10:00pm

Twice?

Moneycounter

11/24/14 8:07am

RE: Holy crap i am so tired of hearing this

Maximumkungfu

11/22/14 7:51am

byu seems to have improved it's recruiting the past 2 years

I'mBatman

11/21/14 11:21am

We need more good OL's. Hopefully we at least need one of Longson, Empey, and

pinolero

11/21/14 11:31am

Utah adding like 8 more guys? Big advantage imo.

johnnycarson

11/21/14 11:30am

I think the mission age change is reducing the number of signees

FiveTen-BuckEighty

11/21/14 11:33am

Utah just jumped us by adding this kid 30 min ago

catawag

11/21/14 11:38am

Why is he flashing the U of Miami sign?

wiscougarfan

11/21/14 11:45am

Well he did commit to utah so that should explain it

catawag

11/21/14 11:46am

RE: Why is he flashing the U of Miami sign?

Sirrinem

11/21/14 11:51am

Ha ha, thats hardly a commitment.

Ebolarama

11/21/14 11:51am

it means we are firmly no 1. say around 75% of landing him

Utesplease

11/21/14 11:52am

75%, sound arbitrary enough

Ebolarama

11/21/14 11:59am

it was a complete guess, yeah. can't deny he is heavily leaning towards utah

Utesplease

11/21/14 12:11pm

Fair, I just take thought it was funny how they stressed he would still be

Ebolarama

11/21/14 12:14pm

really hope he brings he 4 star WR buddy equanimeous st brown

Utesplease

11/21/14 11:51am

It's always been this way. It's just what we do with them that matters.

Zaphod

11/21/14 11:53am

Ding ding ding!!!!!!!

slowhiteguy

11/21/14 12:23pm

There is little to no player development in the Bronco Administration.

BYUisLife

11/21/14 1:47pm

Only proves the point that BYU is underperforming on the field.

Real Men Wear Blue

11/21/14 12:35pm

There are a couple of things to consider here.

afro

11/21/14 12:55pm

How many are thirsty for blood and are excited to knock the snot out of someone?

2239Yfan

11/21/14 2:21pm

It will be all the more painful when our superior recruits lose in 2017

VenetianCougar

11/21/14 3:59pm

Lies!! Made worse by Micah Croom 4 star DB committing today....

crookedUTE

11/21/14 4:33pm

I hate recruiting these days...

Frenemy59

11/21/14 4:42pm

The post is ridiculous...

crookedUTE

11/21/14 4:50pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad