Kryle has gone 6-6, 5-7, 5-7, and both teams have the same record this season. An SOS argument only works if you win your games. Bronco has finished ahead of Kryle in the final standings almost every year they have been coaching. Yes the Head to Head sucks but 1 - Utah has not been dominant no matter how much the hand wringers what to claim otherwise. The games easily could have (and a couple of times should have) gone BYUs way. 2 - It is only one game in the season. I personally cared more about the ND and WI losses last year. 3 - Kryle gets his team up for a few games but every season has a few head scratching losses. Bronco seldom has a loss where the reason isn't apparently obvious. I would much rather have a consistent coach like Bronco than an emotional chameleon like Whit.
So yes I think Bronco is a better coach and I think he is 1000% better for BYU.