what you are talking about. That being said, is there any benefit to come onto a board where he may well be reading, or his family and friends will be, and post such a negative post. You said some positive things but your overall evaluation was not very flattering.

I have no issue with a bunch of guys getting together and talking about recruits. They can say whatever they want about how a certain recruit is a mistake in recruiting, how he can't play at the next level, etc.

But to go on a public board and tell the world that someone isn't a good player? You have not seen him play at the college level and what you say is just an opinion based on what a kid does in HS against HS players. That just doesn't sit well with me. But that is me and many might not see it that way.