Here's a look at the NFL ready players for BYU vs. their opponent during Bronco's coaching tenure. I define NFL ready as being drafted in the NFL within 2 years. For example, in 2012 BYU had 2 NFL ready players on the roster KVN and Ziggy. Taysom or Jamal might indeed turn out to be NFL draft picks, but neither of them were within 2 years of the draft in 2012. Here is the year by year breakdown with the result for BYU
2005
Notre Dame 10 L
Cal 7 L
Boston College 5 L
TCU 5 L
Utah 4 L
New Mexico 3 W
SDSU 2 L
BYU 2
Colorado St. 2 W
Wyoming 2 W
UNLV 1 W
Air Force 0 W
Eastern Illinois 0 W
2006
Arizona 8 L
Oregon 6 W
Boston College 5 L
SDSU 4 W
BYU 2
New Mexico 2 W
Utah 2 W
Utah St. 2 W
TCU 2 W
UNLV 2 W
Colorado St. 1 W
Tulsa 1 W
Wyoming 1 W
Air Force 0 W
2007
Arizona 6 W
SDSU 5 W
TCU 5 W
Utah 4 W
BYU 3
New Mexico 3 W
UCLA 3 L
UCLA 3 W
UNLV 2 W
Tulsa 1 L
Colorado St. 1 W
Air Force 0 W
Wyoming 0 W
Eastern Washington 0 W
2008
Utah 10 L
TCU 8 L
BYU 4
Arizona 4 L
New Mexico 3 W
UCLA 3 W
Colorado St. 2 W
Washington 2 W
UNLV 2 W
SDSU 1 W
Air Force 0 W
Wyoming 0 W
Utah St. 0 W
Northern Iowa 0 W
2009
Oklahoma 11 W
TCU 8 L
Utah 8 W
Florida St. 6 L
Oregon St. 4 W
BYU 2
SDSU 2 W
Colorado St. 1 W
New Mexico 1 W
Wyoming 1 W
Utah St. 1 W
UNLV 1 W
Air Force 0 W
Tulane 0 W
2010
Florida St. 7 L
Nevada 7 L
TCU 7 L
SDSU 6 W
Utah St. 4 L
Washington 4 W
Utah 3 L
Wyoming 1 W
BYU 0
New Mexico 0 W
Colorado St. 0 W
Air Force 0 L
UNLV 0 W
UTEP 0 W
2011
Texas 6 L
Utah St. 5 W
TCU 4 L
Utah 3 L
Central Florida 3 W
Oregon St. 3 W
NMSU 2 W
BYU 1
Tulsa 1 W
San Jose St. 1 W
Mississippi 1 W
Hawaii 1 W
Idaho 1 W
Idaho St. 0 W
2012
Notre Dame 14 L
SDSU 5 W
Boise St 4 L
Utah 4 L
Utah St. 4 W
Oregon St. 4 L
Georgia Tech 3 W
San Jose St. 3 L
BYU 2
Washington St. 2 W
NMSU 1 W
Weber St. 0 W
Hawaii 0 W
Idaho 0 W
2013
Notre Dame 9 L
Wisconsin 7 L
Utah 6 L
Washington 6 L
Georgia Tech 6 W
Virginia 5 L
Texas 5 W
Boise St. 4 W
Utah St. 2 W
BYU 1
Nevada 1 W
MTSU 1 W
Idaho St. 0 W
Houston 0 W
2014 One draft only
Texas 5 W
Memphis 2 L
UCF 2 L
UConn 2 W
Virginia 2 W
BSU 1 L
Houston 0 W
Cal 0 W
Nevada 0 L
MTSU 0 W
UNLV 0 W
USU 0 L
Savannah St. 0 W
BYU 0
BYU vs. teams with more draft picks 27-32.
BYU with as many draft picks 27-6
BYU with more draft picks 36-1