Funhouse, Star Trek Next Generation and T2. High Speed, PinBot, Cyclone etc are much-played classics but not as much replay value as the more complex machines.

I'm a big fan of old Williams machines like F-14 Tomcat, although that one may not translate so well to video since half the fun was the high velocity multiball launch which shot the ball so fast it was scary, often hitting the glass. Taxi on the Wii is pretty addictive even though I never saw that one in real life.

Don't need to revive any addictions right now but this one is fun to consider.