Carroll over Barnes is the only debate.

Thompson is korver, only he plays defense, and can actually do things on offense besides shoot. It's not that close.

Green is so vital to GS defense, he's the easy choice over Millsap.

Not gonna even discuss curry-Teague

Bogut over horford because of how vital he also is to GS defense.

Now if we're talking about the individual players with no regards to fitting on the team, horford trumps bogut and green edges out Millsap, but it's close.