PK

Jun 30, 2015
11:55:49am

Biyamiti

I would also add to what others have said that when running at breakaway speed it is also a lot more likely to make a mistake with a bad touch on the ball that allows the keeper to save it.

This message has been modified

Originally posted on Jun 30, 2015 at 11:55:49am

Message modified by Biyamiti on Jun 30, 2015 at 12:01:35pm

Report problem with this ad

Biyamiti

Previous username: skywalker251
Bio page: Biyamiti
Joined: Mar 1, 2006
Last login: Apr 23, 2024
Total posts: 7,148 (49 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Soccer question: Which is more difficult to stop a penalty kick or a breakaway

Thrill

6/30/15 11:46am

Probably a PK because of the "stand on the goal line" rule

Yoshinobu

6/30/15 11:47am

This used to be a thing back in the old NASL.

rad dawg

6/30/15 11:48am

Only 1 of 10 opportunities on this highlight resulted in a goal. With PKs it

Thrill

6/30/15 11:56am

I think it was the same in the early days of MLS...

ToonArmyCoug

6/30/15 11:59am

I kind of like this approach.. similar to indoor soccer

buhler08

6/30/15 12:07pm

Biggest downside would have to be increased likelihood of injuries

buhler08

6/30/15 12:14pm

Count it as a goal and play on

rggee

6/30/15 12:19pm

Who knew? Mr. Kotter was a pretty good goalie.

gwalker

6/30/15 12:32pm

That sure is entertaining to watch

Ynutter

6/30/15 2:37pm

Avery

6/30/15 11:49am

Breakaway, not even a question. If you can't score 1-on-1 when you are free to

Left Shark Coug

6/30/15 11:50am

you're wrong, actually. it can be very difficult to score on a break away,

erkimust

6/30/15 11:54am

Perhaps I misunderstood him, but he seemed to be talking about making penalty

Left Shark Coug

6/30/15 11:57am

RE: Perhaps I misunderstood him, but he seemed to be talking about making

rggee

6/30/15 12:00pm

The key is the keeper coming off of his line, making the goal smaller

buhler08

6/30/15 12:03pm

I think you're wrong in that case too. the keeper not being able to come off

erkimust

6/30/15 12:05pm

If there's a time limit, like the video above, that would make sense.

Left Shark Coug

6/30/15 12:08pm

RE: If there's a time limit, like the video above, that would make sense.

rggee

6/30/15 12:17pm

Not when the goalie can run toward you, making the angles much more difficult to

rggee

6/30/15 11:56am

And when a slight tap of the ball right or left sends the goalie into chase mode

Left Shark Coug

6/30/15 12:06pm

You still have a much smaller angle to shoot the ball without missing the goal.

rggee

6/30/15 12:07pm

The goalie is now beside you. It's wide open. What angle?

Left Shark Coug

6/30/15 12:09pm

The goalie will stay in front of you if he's any good.

rggee

6/30/15 12:18pm

A "slight" tap wouldn't put any goalie into chase mode

buhler08

6/30/15 12:12pm

I'd like to see one of these amazing goalies who could dive on a ball before a

Left Shark Coug

6/30/15 12:19pm

RE: I'd like to see one of these amazing goalies who could dive on a ball before

rggee

6/30/15 12:21pm

I'm willing to change my opinion, but I'd like to see some footage with pro's

Left Shark Coug

6/30/15 12:34pm

Who ever said anything about no time limit besides yourself

buhler08

6/30/15 12:28pm

Dude, chill the yewt out. It's clear that nobody in this thread understood

Left Shark Coug

6/30/15 12:37pm

Clearly you don't know soccer

buhler08

6/30/15 11:56am

This is just plain wrong.

sheriffcreg

6/30/15 12:16pm

PK. Two things with a breakaway (in game) is that (1) the goalie can come

Coach's Dad

6/30/15 11:53am

heh. see my post above. we said the exact same thing.

erkimust

6/30/15 11:55am

Can I get a ruling from Jefe on how many seconds it actually was?

Coach's Dad

6/30/15 11:56am

Would a breakaway shootout be better/more exciting than a PK shootout?

Thrill

6/30/15 11:59am

Maybe a little, but PKs are already pretty exciting. Change other things first.

Coach's Dad

6/30/15 12:16pm

Biyamiti

6/30/15 11:55am

Per my earlier rantings I would say a PK

Posting on CougarBoard