With this addendum:

Nov 30, 2015
11:26:54am

Byron McNertney All-American

With this addendum:

61 out of 65 teams in P5 conferences will not make the playoff and, realistically, around 50 of them have around an equal or worse shot at it than BYU does.

Report problem with this ad

Byron McNertney

Previous username: sonofchet
Bio page: Byron McNertney
Joined: Nov 24, 2006
Last login: Apr 18, 2024
Total posts: 57,146 (13,764 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

POLL: I understand that BYU has no guaranteed NY6 access while the AAC/G5 does?

yfootball

11/30/15 11:16am

this feels like a question at the DMV

johnnycarson

11/30/15 11:17am

Disclaimer:

yfootball

11/30/15 11:17am

It's the highest ranked G5 CHAMPION

boscatar

11/30/15 11:20am

This is true, and part of the reason why BYU does not qualify.

yfootball

11/30/15 11:25am

You should follow it up with this poll:

byujacob

11/30/15 11:20am

Uh, ok. Completely disagree.

yfootball

11/30/15 11:22am

You really think BYU going undefeated in the AAC or MWC is more likely to get them a top 4 ranking

byujacob

11/30/15 11:24am

BYU undefeated gets in under any scenario

pink22

11/30/15 11:26am

So you think undefeated Memphis would get in this year?

TaiJuan

11/30/15 11:28am

BYU reputation >>>> Memphis reputation

pink22

11/30/15 11:30am

that's crazy

byujacob

11/30/15 11:31am

I'm as down on BYU currently as anyone. But all things being equal, BYU football

pink22

11/30/15 11:33am

I think part of that is because BYU is independent, which would change as a member of the AAC.

TaiJuan

11/30/15 11:34am

My assumption is we still play a decent team or two non conference

pink22

11/30/15 11:40am

2001 would have to disagree

buhler08

11/30/15 11:35am

2001 was a different animal

pink22

11/30/15 11:41am

You're right.. it was 10 teams instead of 4..

buhler08

11/30/15 11:44am

You act like an Ny6 is now meaningless. This is your opinion and that is fine,

yfootball

11/30/15 11:29am

You made two claims in your post

buhler08

11/30/15 11:29am

Fair points. Sure, I'd rather be in a NY6 bowl than the Vegas or Hawaii bowl, but I strongly believe

byujacob

11/30/15 11:35am

And while they might miss out on the G5 guarantee, a solid top ten season would put them in play for at-large bErth.

TaiJuan

11/30/15 11:38am

I'll agree with that, for the most part

buhler08

11/30/15 11:42am

With this addendum:

Byron McNertney

11/30/15 11:26am

Your options could certainly be better worded...

BYUFam1

11/30/15 11:27am

True. and already mentioned above.

yfootball

11/30/15 11:30am

Has BYU ever been "left out" or "looked over"?

CosmoK

11/30/15 11:28am

BYU HAS to be top 12 minimum (most years higher) to get an at-large

BYUFam1

11/30/15 11:32am

Is that the "math" or the "rule"?

CosmoK

11/30/15 11:45am

I know with 100% certainty that they CAN NOT pick BYU in your scenario

BYUFam1

11/30/15 11:49am

Could, but don't have to, and most likely wouldn't

buhler08

11/30/15 11:50am

If BYU is never the highest ranked non-P5, then this discussion is pointless

Posting on CougarBoard