My Account
Sign up, and you can customize which countdowns you see.
Sign up
Report problem with this ad
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Dec 1, 2015
1:52
:01
pm
4mack
All-American
Seems premature to put Toolson in that mix, although he played well last game
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Report problem with this ad
4mack
Bio page
4mack
Joined
Nov 17, 2010
Last login
Apr 22, 2024
Total posts
8,869 (217 FO)
Report problem with this ad
Messages
Author
Time
BYU all time starting 5. PG Jimmer SG Ainge SF KCollinsworth PF Cosic C Bradley
buckeyecougarguy
12/1/15 1:41pm
*Cosic
fredgarvin
12/1/15 1:44pm
thanks.
buckeyecougarguy
12/1/15 1:45pm
I'd go Smith over Bradley. Bradley only played 1 year.
fredgarvin
12/1/15 1:44pm
Certainly had the better overall career numbers, but did he go as deep in the
buckeyecougarguy
12/1/15 1:46pm
Neither got past the second round of the tournament.
fredgarvin
12/1/15 1:52pm
Bradley doesn't belong there IMO - only played 1 year
FiveTen-BuckEighty
12/1/15 1:45pm
May want to consider a 2nd all time team. I would include Toolson, Haws, Araujo
MajorZeus
12/1/15 1:45pm
Seems premature to put Toolson in that mix, although he played well last game
4mack
12/1/15 1:52pm
funny
fulano
12/1/15 1:56pm
Araujo? Really? I'd like to hear that argument
Hank Rearden
12/1/15 1:53pm
I'll go with same except put Travis Hansen at the 3.
thebruce
12/1/15 1:46pm
Over KC? I wouldn't. At the college level KC does everything better except shoot
mantis mutu
12/1/15 2:39pm
Travis was a much, much better defender IMO
thebruce
12/1/15 2:54pm
Calling KC the much better "shooter" was an obvious brain poop on my part
mantis mutu
12/1/15 2:57pm
In a lineup of jimmer and ainge do you want KC handling the ball?
thebruce
12/1/15 3:01pm
I honestly think Travis's D was always a bit over-rated. I thought he used his
mantis mutu
12/1/15 3:06pm
Good discussion. The thing that made Travis
thebruce
12/1/15 3:44pm
I'd go Smith over KC at SF. or put him at PF, moving Cosic to C
smokymountainrain
12/1/15 1:47pm
I thought about Cosic over Bradley at Center... But i like that rim protection.
buckeyecougarguy
12/1/15 1:49pm
Bradley averaged over 5 blocks per game. Next were Kite, Hartsock <1.86
buckeyecougarguy
12/1/15 1:57pm
Smith wasn't a SF. He was a PF/C.
fredgarvin
12/1/15 1:53pm
Smith could play all three positions and did play all three.
smokymountainrain
12/1/15 2:23pm
Agree, but still, calling him a small forward at BYU would be a stretch.
fredgarvin
12/1/15 2:35pm
And I agree with that. I just need him on the team - and if that means
smokymountainrain
12/1/15 2:39pm
Fair enough. He's first-team for sure.
fredgarvin
12/1/15 2:43pm
No Jimmy Balderson????
mobomanjoe
12/1/15 1:48pm
also tempted by James Anderson- the highest winning percentage of any byu player
buckeyecougarguy
12/1/15 1:49pm
Best all-time scrub?
mantis mutu
12/1/15 2:42pm
What about Araujo? I was on my mission when he played, but heard RAVE reviews
WhiteKnight
12/1/15 1:54pm
I was on my mission too. I think he makes the second team.
buckeyecougarguy
12/1/15 1:57pm
Devin Durrant should get a look on that list.
Iman23
12/1/15 1:58pm
I think Durrant and Haws are on my next man out. I think theres a difference in
buckeyecougarguy
12/1/15 2:12pm
Jimmer, Ainge, Durrant, Smith, Cosic
fredgarvin
12/1/15 2:00pm
Mostly agree. However, Haws should be there some place - probably 2nd team
Zenoch
12/1/15 2:05pm
Yeah, you're probably right. Should have put Haws over Chatman or Hansen.
fredgarvin
12/1/15 2:12pm
RE: BYU all time starting 5. PG Jimmer SG Ainge SF KCollinsworth PF Cosic C
manxcoug
12/1/15 2:02pm
what about Mel Hutchins?
JOPE
12/1/15 2:02pm
Coached by Coach Rose, but
buckeyecougarguy
12/1/15 2:03pm
Fred Roberts had a long career in the NBA and was a great BYU player
JohnHaddow
12/1/15 2:14pm
1. Cosic, 2. Ainge, 3. Bradley, 4. Hutchins, 5. Collinsworth.
roseyscenario
12/1/15 2:28pm
Mel Hutchins, nice. Back when they played with actual baskets instead of hoops;
thebruce
12/1/15 2:33pm
As Dr J says, all time greats are usually emotional picks. i like to judge by how they dominated their
roseyscenario
12/1/15 2:41pm
No Jimmer? Do you work for the Bulls, Spurs, Pelicans or Kings?
buckeyecougarguy
12/1/15 2:35pm
No kidding. Jimmer is to the bball program what Ty was to football.
UNLVcougar
12/1/15 2:42pm
Ty definitely wouldn't be my all time QB either, though. Not even backup.
mantis mutu
12/1/15 2:50pm
Love Ty and Jimmer. Young and McMahon at least come ahead of him. Possibly 2 to 5 others.
roseyscenario
12/1/15 4:17pm
You can't leave off the POY.
macaroni
12/1/15 4:00pm
For as one-way & blackhole of a player as Jimmer was--you can, I think.
mantis mutu
12/1/15 4:24pm
He did shoot poorly in the Sweet 16 game.
roseyscenario
12/1/15 4:35pm
That calf injury really effected the lift on his jumper, I think. It's too bad.
mantis mutu
12/1/15 4:52pm
Yeah because he was completely exhausted. And even then he was still scoring. I think that saying that KC kept them in
macaroni
12/1/15 5:06pm
I dont think the supporting cast was the reason for Jimmer. Jimmer was the
buckeyecougarguy
12/1/15 5:00pm
They definitely didn't make Jimmer--but they did all the dirty work VERY well.
mantis mutu
12/1/15 5:02pm
Good thought. I'd take Russell Larson over Bradley, though. So long as we
mantis mutu
12/1/15 2:45pm
Except that Larson was one of the biggest chokers in byu bball history. Guy couldn't be counted on when it mattered.
macaroni
12/1/15 4:00pm
It was a sad ending for him. Knew his lil bro. He didn't like playing for Reid.
mantis mutu
12/1/15 4:16pm
Report problem with this ad
Posting on CougarBoard
In order to post, you will need to either
sign up
or
log in
.
Report problem with this ad
