My brothers and I talk about rating coaches the way players are rated in madden:
- Knowledge (KNW): How well they understand Xs and Os
- Teaching (TCH): How well they develop players and teach fundamentals
- Play Calling (PCL): How well they select plays during a game
- Recruiting (RCT): How well does the coach recruit
- Public Relations (PRN): How well does the coach do with media, alumni, students
- Inspiration (ISP): How well a coach can get players up for a big game
- Staff Management (SMG): How well does a coach find and develop staff
So, for examples:
Lavell Edwards
- KNW: 85
- TCH: 88
- PCL: 82
- RCT: 82
- PRN: 89
- ISP: 84
- SMG: 97
Gary Crowton
- KNW: 92
- TCH: 72
- PCL: 89
- RCT: 89
- PRN: 84
- ISP: 79
- SMG: 80
Bronco Mendenhall
- KNW: 91
- TCH: 83
- PCL: 89
- RCT: 79
- PRN: 73
- ISP: 75
- SMG: 82
Robert Anae
- KNW: 85
- TCH: 91
- PCL: 82
- RCT: 75
- PRN: 65
- ISP: 78
- SMG: 86
Any categories you'd like to add? How would you rate these coaches? How would you rate other coaches?