it's hypothetical... We don't know how much better Tanner is than Taysom passing because Tanner hasn't thrown a pass yet this year. Also, what is not included in your hypothetical is the potential for others to get more yards running the ball due to the respect defenses would need to have on the back side. In other words, it would be foolish to line up 8 and 9 in the box vs Tanner, he has the ability to make a team pay for that... Therefore, Jamaal would have better holes to run through...Hypothetically of course!