It seems pretty much everyone agrees Collie is the number one BYU receiver of all time. I loved Collie, and proved he had the talent by sticking in the NFL before concussions got to him. But I think I'd take Hoffman. Collie was awesome but played with some great quarterbacks (who maybe were great because they played with guys like him), but Hoffman to me played as dominant as he did with some sketchy quarterback play, and was incredible at coming down with tough catches with corners draped all over him. Am I forgetting how amazing Collie was? Or is there any chance if you swap out quarterbacks that Hoffman would be an easy number one for college football (obviously Collie had the NFL career)