No, I'm not. My argument is that the crowd is the most important part of home

Sign up, and you can make all message times appear in your timezone. Sign up

Report problem with this ad

Jun 19, 2017
7:14:00pm

chilango All-American

No, I'm not. My argument is that the crowd is the most important part of home

field advantage, by far, because of its influence on the referees. Playing in a site that guarantees a very one-sided crowd bestows the most critical element of home field advantage one one of the teams. In this case, LSU.

http://www.cougarboard.com/board/message.html?id=17929208

This message has been modified

Originally posted on Jun 19, 2017 at 7:14:00pm

Message modified by chilango on Jun 19, 2017 at 7:14:31pm

Report problem with this ad

chilango

Bio page: chilango
Joined: Jul 23, 2009
Last login: Dec 27, 2020
Total posts: 25,771 (33 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

POLL: Best scheduling agreement as an Independent:

Gentleman Stan All-American

6/19/17 2:45pm

Has to be Missouri: Neutral there and Home in November against an SEC opponent.

6/19/17 2:48pm

I'd take Stanford (2/2 with 2 November games) over that. Or Virginia (2/1 in BYU's favor). But you're

6/19/17 2:54pm

Virginia is a combo of coach buyout or trade

SouthernBlueBlood

6/19/17 2:57pm

I know, but it resulted in a home/home turning into a 2/1 for BYU.

6/19/17 3:27pm

My only issue with the Stanford deal is that both Nov games are on the road.

6/19/17 2:58pm

I think it's a good trade off- good games in November away from Utah in warm California makes sense

SouthernBlueBlood

6/19/17 3:03pm

Great for recruiting too. See Notre Dame

boscatar

6/20/17 8:17am

LSU "neutral" site -- LOL.

chilango

6/19/17 2:54pm

It's a 4 hour drive and in a different State. Yes, they'll outnumber BYU by a wide margin.

6/19/17 2:59pm

Man- LSU in Houston is a home game- so many LSU fans all over Houston

SouthernBlueBlood

6/19/17 3:03pm

Is it being played at Tiger Stadium in Baton Rouge? Then it's not a home game.

foofcoug

6/19/17 3:09pm

I predict it will be sold out 20% BYU- that's pretty home worthy

SouthernBlueBlood

6/19/17 3:11pm

Still not a home game not matter how you slice it.

foofcoug

6/19/17 3:13pm

It is in the way that matters most: crowd influence on the refereeing. Studies

chilango

6/19/17 6:32pm

Still not a home game. If Oregon and Michigan State play in the Rose Bowl, there will likely be more

6/19/17 6:46pm

Bad comparison, because the fans would be fairly evenly split. Playing LSU in

chilango

6/19/17 6:57pm

Now you're switching arguments.

6/19/17 7:02pm

No, I'm not. My argument is that the crowd is the most important part of home

chilango

6/19/17 7:14pm

Studies haven't shown that. You cited the one "study" from a site called freakonomics.

6/19/17 11:12pm

Can you cite any studies that have reached a different conclusion?

chilango

6/20/17 4:43am

Freakonomics didn't sponsor or publish the study. They just wrote an article

Geldir

6/20/17 4:46am

If we get to 20%, it will be an accomplishment.

chilango

6/19/17 6:37pm

Yes, it will be much more like a home game for LSU. That doesn't change the fact that it's a neutral.

LiveCoug

6/19/17 6:54pm

More LSU fans in Houston than UH fans

WorfoSAUR

6/19/17 3:08pm

Boise State. G5 label aside, a 12 yr deal with one of the best programs in CFB.

CaliWG

6/19/17 3:33pm

You're right if this game was in November it would be so much better

SouthernBlueBlood

6/19/17 6:55pm

Either Stanford or USC (my vote) meaningful games in November are huge

84 Grad

6/19/17 3:39pm

What about Wisky home/home?

BYU '80

6/20/17 7:54am

Thought that was a delayed 2 for 1: 2013 at Wisky, 2017 in Provo, 2018 at Wisky.

6/20/17 8:34am

You could be right. I didn't remember the 2018 game

BYU '80

6/20/17 6:11pm

I am leery of the 2x home/home games w/ Stanford

FatherOFive

6/21/17 7:48am

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad