No.. no. They wouldn't be if Indi were helping the product on the field. Its not

Sign up, and CougarBoard will remember which categories you want to view. Sign up

Report problem with this ad

Sep 25, 2017
3:11:28pm

Turbine All-American

No.. no. They wouldn't be if Indi were helping the product on the field. Its not

Report problem with this ad

Turbine

Previous username: yfootball
Bio page: Turbine
Joined: Oct 18, 2010
Last login: Nov 24, 2017
Total posts: 8,826 (64 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

I have a fairly well connected booster friend that I recently asked about Indy

kosmokramer

9/25/17 2:40pm

There's a problem right there

TNT

9/25/17 2:41pm

I am not surprised. This is probably true for most universities with football.

SandYFan

9/25/17 2:42pm

BYU is different obviously

TNT

9/25/17 2:43pm

yes but with many of those schools it's the football program that gets what...

icecougar

9/25/17 7:53pm

Been that way forever. Twofold since Crowton

Moab Rising

9/25/17 2:46pm

Oh TNT has understood this for a long time

TNT

9/25/17 2:50pm

Question

runningryan

9/25/17 4:30pm

I know Tom was a big supporter of it initially but...

insidebyu

9/25/17 7:02pm

what stinks is there are almost no options...

icecougar

9/25/17 8:05pm

Limitations on fundraising is troubling

jkccoug

9/25/17 8:32pm

You'd think so, but...

insidebyu

9/26/17 8:18am

In other words...BYU will never be a P5 because of internal restraints

boscatar

9/26/17 5:04pm

In other words, but is on life support as myself and many others have said.

Backcountry

9/25/17 8:43pm

It is too bad they won't allow more donations for sports.

9/25/17 9:28pm

Why are all these posts from trolls?

9/25/17 2:44pm

To which point are you referring?

TNT

9/25/17 2:45pm

That stepping down to a G5 would be anything but a death sentence for BYU.

BYUtka

9/25/17 2:47pm

You mean stepping sideways to a G5

Polecat

9/25/17 3:27pm

It's not sideways

MormonThug

9/25/17 3:54pm

Yes it is

Polecat

9/25/17 5:31pm

That thinking is sideways, but it is a clear downgrade. It isn't even close to

BYUtka

9/25/17 5:38pm

Agreed 100%. G5 is the kiss of death for BYU football.

CougarThug

9/25/17 8:08pm

No, and you know it's not. Indy is much better.

9/25/17 6:08pm

BYU is still a viable need for a G5 conference that they could get...

Coug

9/25/17 9:46pm

Only if by sideways you mean "off a cliff into a dark void." Indy>G5.

BYUtka

9/25/17 4:30pm

You don't believe the "connected booster" has inside info?

cougarnw

9/25/17 3:18pm

Frankly, no.

CougarThug

9/25/17 8:09pm

Definitely not a troll

kosmokramer

9/25/17 4:11pm

Suggesting that BYU would benefit from dropping down to G5 is 100% a troll move.

BYUtka

9/25/17 4:18pm

Everything great BYU accomplished was as a member of a lower

kosmokramer

9/25/17 5:04pm

The landscape has changed a lot since then. You cannot ignore that.

BYUtka

9/25/17 5:27pm

It has, but that doesn't make Indy any better.

kosmokramer

9/25/17 6:32pm

BYU is in a unique situation compared to other schools. You are ignoring that.

BYUtka

9/25/17 7:12pm

Not true. The BCS and P5 were both designed to exclude non-members

CougarThug

9/25/17 8:24pm

that was also when the conference we were in had Utah

mindzeYe

9/25/17 11:18pm

No, it goes around for people who post obvious lies and nonsense

9/25/17 5:28pm

This is getting SO TIRESOME! There are NO ALTERNATIVES!

DirtyWater

9/25/17 2:46pm

YeS There aRe!

Backcountry

9/25/17 2:49pm

G5 is not a viable alternative. It would kill the program.

BYUtka

9/25/17 2:56pm

We were G5 for 30 years leading up to independence

boscatar

9/25/17 2:58pm

And so was Utah. They are P5 now... THAT is the key difference.

BYUtka

9/25/17 3:01pm

And being Indy doesn't make us P5, just not G5

BYU Fan

9/25/17 3:45pm

Sure, a G5 all star conference would be cool.. but at best that's even with indy

Dissenter

9/25/17 7:47pm

The landscape has changed dramatically. You can't compare our previous

9/25/17 3:03pm

This is true. In the 80s and 90s it didn't matter which conference a bowl

Stalwart Man

9/25/17 7:24pm

Staying indy and faking like we're a quasi P5 isn't doing us any favors either

franklyvulgar

9/25/17 3:35pm

It is hurting us less than dropping to g5 would.

BYUtka

9/25/17 4:27pm

Please stop

DirtyWater

9/25/17 2:56pm

After you stop with all caps and definitive statements.

Backcountry

9/25/17 3:41pm

Good grief. Of course there is

shakarocks

9/25/17 3:01pm

Hmm... I guess USF, Boise, SDSU, Memphis, Houston etc didn't get the memo.

Turbine

9/25/17 3:10pm

Apples to Oranges.

BYUtka

9/25/17 4:28pm

They did get the memo, and they fought to get P5, hard.

Dissenter

9/25/17 7:48pm

According to CB they should be long dead by now and done with football... Odd

Turbine

9/25/17 8:39pm

Not what anyone here is saying.

BYUtka

9/25/17 9:25pm

A death sentence? It's EXACTLY what some people are claiming.

Turbine

9/25/17 10:42pm

And for BYU, it would be. No one said it was for other schools. They are not BYU

BYUtka

9/26/17 12:45am

Of course there is an alternative. That is lazy thinking

kosmokramer

9/25/17 4:16pm

This is how people drown in a sinking ship; of course, there are alternatives!

insidebyu

9/25/17 7:05pm

RE: I have a fairly well connected booster friend that I recently asked about Indy

9/25/17 2:46pm

I don't believe him either

kahuna

9/25/17 4:27pm

Nobody would be raising this Indy talk if we were winning

Goliath

9/25/17 2:46pm

Yeah but we're not, and haven't been for 9 years now.

SandYFan

9/25/17 2:47pm

and going G5 will make us win again? How, but diluting our competition?

Archaea

9/25/17 3:14pm

I'm not advocating G5. It's P5 or die./

SandYFan

9/25/17 3:16pm

No.. no. They wouldn't be if Indi were helping the product on the field. Its not

Turbine

9/25/17 3:11pm

Nobody ever said it is. It's about EXPOSURE

Dissenter

9/25/17 7:49pm

Exposure is worthless if not helping on field.

Turbine

9/25/17 8:38pm

I think you are missing the point

kosmokramer

9/25/17 4:18pm

G5 won't cure our problem with front-loaded schedules! It'll make it worse.

Stalwart Man

9/25/17 7:27pm

This is what the G5 crowd doesn't get. We'd play the same teams in G5

Dissenter

9/25/17 7:50pm

If that's the case then I doubt we're headed to a conference any time soon

jkccoug

9/25/17 2:47pm

I think you may be right

kosmokramer

9/25/17 4:19pm

I don't think anyone really thinks indy is sustainable long term

Baron

9/25/17 2:47pm

It's not. TH has said it isn't.

Mathew

9/25/17 2:51pm

So we're basically saying that non-P5 isn't sustainable long-term. Maybe...

Stalwart Man

9/25/17 7:28pm

I think the newer Indy schedules will help. Better end of season games.

jkccoug

9/25/17 2:51pm

2018 schedule has Boise St. and Utah in November...

boscatar

9/25/17 2:57pm

Sounds legit

jaromp

9/25/17 2:54pm

Was Bronco filling up with premium or regular?

boscatar

9/25/17 2:56pm

It was a private booster meeting.

kosmokramer

9/25/17 4:07pm

At the end of the day, sports are about entertainment

Ulysses14

9/25/17 2:56pm

Lies! Football is life

TNT

9/25/17 2:59pm

I thought pinball was life? Is TNT living a dual life? I smell a dupe account!

TheWanderer

9/25/17 3:26pm

Indy is sustainable for football as long as ESPN pays BYU fairly for its home games.

9/25/17 2:57pm

And it is certainly more sustainable than dropping down to G5.

BYUtka

9/25/17 3:04pm

I see G5 is more of a side step than down step I think Indy is overrated

franklyvulgar

9/25/17 3:46pm

How is it not a down step? It is a negative tragectory. It moves us backward.

BYUtka

9/25/17 3:48pm

Indy was a temporary landing spot until the P5 happened it appears that door is

franklyvulgar

9/25/17 4:00pm

How is it a downstep?

kosmokramer

9/25/17 4:12pm

Ok, now I am convinced you are just trolling.

BYUtka

9/25/17 4:31pm

Do you think we'd have 10 games a year on national TV in a G5??

Stalwart Man

9/25/17 7:30pm

See definitions 2 & 3 in the link below.

Refugee

9/25/17 3:21pm

My meeting with Bronco is 100% fact

kosmokramer

9/25/17 4:10pm

Didn't say your meeting wasn't legit. Read the definitions again.

Refugee

9/25/17 4:32pm

fair enough, I guess most anything shared on here meets the definition of

kosmokramer

9/25/17 6:35pm

If we joined a G5, wouldn't we have to pay a lot of money to break future game

ordinatuer

9/25/17 3:32pm

No facts huh about why Holmoe would want to go G5? They can make any schedule

Bobmarleyjr

9/25/17 3:37pm

I am pretty sure TH would love to not have to be putting together

kosmokramer

9/25/17 4:13pm

Not to mention many of the high profile P5 teams refuse to give us a return game

franklyvulgar

9/25/17 4:16pm

P5 need us bc of the ooc P5 requirements & we can't expect to be even Home games

Bobmarleyjr

9/25/17 4:23pm

Nobody noticed that the P5 quit caring about the OOC requirements.

jrj84105

9/25/17 4:48pm

Nope. They only ignored it for really bad teams that couldn't win

Bobmarleyjr

9/25/17 8:18pm

The only P5 teams that didn't schedule P5 OOC were the bad teams.

jrj84105

9/26/17 8:45am

Those that want a good OOC game for CFP want to play BYU if best available

Bobmarleyjr

9/26/17 3:07pm

Those same "lackluster" bowls are what the G5 are playing for.

CougarThug

9/25/17 8:32pm

He doesn't even do it. He just approves it & all G5 move schedules for TV & P5

Bobmarleyjr

9/25/17 4:18pm

So if the B12 would have invited us the higher ups would have said no

Oldcougfan

9/25/17 3:51pm

Don't hold your breath

jkccoug

9/25/17 3:54pm

I didn't say that, but I do believe they had reservations.

kosmokramer

9/25/17 6:36pm

Here's my solution:

boscatar

9/25/17 3:53pm

I like it.

ordinatuer

9/25/17 3:57pm

That could happen on a smaller scale

runningryan

9/25/17 4:51pm

I could live with that.

HowardH

9/25/17 5:14pm

This would be the best combination for football independence. Would be awesome if it could work

9/25/17 5:26pm

It is a lot like what I suggested years ago...

kosmokramer

9/25/17 6:41pm

Sounds like Wac-16, the second coming, but has intriguing possibilities

insidebyu

9/25/17 7:08pm

Is this a personal attack?

TonyStark

9/25/17 3:58pm

Did he say that's why he sucked in recruiting and rivalry games?

Y4LYFE

9/25/17 4:13pm

his recruiting was comparable to LaVell's

kosmokramer

9/25/17 4:15pm

saying that current coaches prefer g5 over indy is not true.

HarlemCoug

9/25/17 4:13pm

You may be correct

kosmokramer

9/25/17 4:16pm

TH does not prefer G5 to Indy.

HarlemCoug

9/25/17 4:17pm

Only Yewt trolls prefer BYU is G5 over Indy.

BYUtka

9/25/17 4:45pm

LOL...nothing I hate more than Utes. I just wish we had a better strategy

kosmokramer

9/25/17 6:44pm

BYU fans only have one pre-approved opinion? Anyone else is a Ute troll?

insidebyu

9/25/17 7:09pm

Some things are so clealy bad that only a Yewt wanting the demise of BYU could

BYUtka

9/25/17 7:21pm

this narrative is perplexing to me. BM's exit is the most obvious case that this board doesn't agree on important items

HarlemCoug

9/25/17 8:01pm

You mean not everyone on CB ran him out of town with pitchforks, what?!

insidebyu

9/26/17 8:20am

Bronco told me TH was all in trying to get us into a P5 league.

kosmokramer

9/25/17 6:47pm

Bronco was adamant that the ONLY way out of independence was to play the best teams possible year in and year out and

Rhino84

9/25/17 4:20pm

Bronco was hopeful at the time that P5 would happen

kosmokramer

9/25/17 6:51pm

Revenues aside, a big difference between Indy and affiliation (even G5) has to b

PowerD

9/25/17 4:29pm

Interesting point, never thought about that.

kosmokramer

9/25/17 6:52pm

I call bull... mainly because all the other teams ARE in a respectable conferenc

(Private)

9/25/17 4:41pm

I was only referring to football coaches.

kosmokramer

9/25/17 6:54pm

Not true. FB is the cash cow. The BOT "drives" the decisions and always will.

CougarThug

9/25/17 8:30pm

Seems like a business issue/problem. How closely should the university listen to

Pasadena

9/25/17 6:25pm

We were just fine before in the MWC

CougarWildcat

9/25/17 7:17pm

Yep, and nothing in College Football has changed since then.

BYUtka

9/25/17 7:22pm

I was doing just fine when I worked at a tire shop in High School. Fun times but it would be disastrous to my family if

Rhino84

9/25/17 9:27pm

What? Do you not remember the dumpster fire that was "The Mountain"?

delux_247

9/26/17 5:25am

Bronco is in his 2nd year with VIRGINIA, could BYU beat VIRGINIA this year?

FootFAN

9/26/17 7:10am

dumb ? we all know we couldn't

mindzeYe

9/28/17 2:16am

Not so dumb. Just a few weeks ago we KNEW we could. What we didn't know we didn't know...

Refugee

9/28/17 9:38am

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad