You said it...Green Bay was 4-1 before Rogers went down.
BYU’s offense was anemic in all of Tanner’s games with the exception of SJSU. Ula provides a spark against Utah but we still only managed one TD. Not enough to win a game.
Had we looked good against PSU, and shown any life LSU, and then had a 3 or 4 TD performance against Utah in a loss...you might have a point.