I thought it might have been (Cougrrrs Roll) - CougarBoard.com

Report problem with this ad

Jul 12, 2012 - 11:37am

Cougrrrs Roll

I thought it might have been

the other way around since Wrubell's article was only four days before your post. I had read it and when I saw your post I at first thought you had taken Wrubell's data and expanded on it since it was so similar and had the same subject, BYU senior quarterbacks.

But apparently you hadn't seen his article.

----

-----

Fully Invested Cougar for Mitt Romney

Report problem with this ad

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Date

The facts about how BYU does with returning senior QBs (long)

Jul 11, 12:51am

That's actually a great job of collecting data.

Jul 11, 12:56am

I dont' know about others, but my point has always been

Jul 11, 01:28am

I get your point. I just don't agree with it.

Jul 11, 01:31am

How did he disregard the stocks / players

BYUFam1

Jul 11, 08:26am

Making an NFL team is not a magic line one crosses

Jul 11, 06:02am

always the hater (nm)

Jericho

Jul 11, 09:04am

I prefer 'realistic'

Jul 11, 09:29am

Whiner is not the same as "realistic"

Jericho

Jul 11, 10:03am

You disappoint me.

Jul 11, 10:26am

wrong again (nm)

Jericho

Jul 11, 10:47am

Really? Japan Coug put together some facts and all you

Mathew

Jul 11, 10:08am

Your not being realistic at all. Based on Nelson's #'s,

Jul 11, 10:52am

Hahahaaa that was juicy.

Jul 11, 11:07am

when you say you have followed him since HS

Jericho

Jul 11, 11:09am

I mean I hope I am proved wrong this coming year.

Jul 11, 11:14am

. (nm)

Jul 11, 11:19am

good post. very informative. riley will go undefeated. (nm)

Jul 11, 01:01am

<< Deleted >> (nm)

Jul 11, 01:06am

<< Retracted>> (nm)

Jul 11, 01:14am

"2012: Better than 1988!?" (nm)

Mars

Jul 11, 01:35am

That's actually better than "Every day is game day" (nm)

Jul 11, 01:41am

POTD nominated (nm)

Jul 11, 01:40am

Would you be rooting for Riley if he were not American? (nm)

Jul 11, 01:59am

Yes, he plays for my team. (nm)

Jul 11, 02:04am

but your team is not Japanese. (nm)

Jul 11, 02:05am

JP made a good post. you are making the thread worse. (nm)

Jul 11, 02:07am

no it was just continuation of a good post. to each his own (short)

Jul 11, 02:13am

I usually laugh when something is funny.

Jul 11, 02:26am

This is a big stat the opposite way as well....

idacoug

Jul 11, 04:12am

Nice point. That is often overlooked. (nm)

Jul 11, 06:00am

Covey was a jr in 1988 (short)

Yz1

Jul 11, 05:13am

Are you sure? I thought he was a junior in '87, and a

Jul 11, 07:45am

Just verified it -- you are correct. I will edit my post

Jul 11, 07:46am

Feterik is the only one listed to lose to Utah as a Senior. (nm)

Jul 11, 07:00am

Good observation, added it to the post (nm)

Jul 11, 07:54am

Steve Lindsley was a senior who started most of 1986. Your

basman

Jul 11, 08:38am

But Lindsley only started his Senior year, so he wouldn't be

Jul 11, 08:43am

No one wants to compare Riley to a realistic scenario

Jul 11, 09:36am

Riley had 3 starts in 2010 before being injured

BYUFam1

Jul 11, 09:43am

adding up all of Riley's starts, it closely equals 2 full (short)

viper

Jul 11, 10:03am

I wasn't counting his USU starts

BYUFam1

Jul 11, 10:07am

Well, I think USU was 8 games but you are right.

viper

Jul 11, 10:28am

The better question. Who would even replace him?

Jul 13, 01:54am

I was about to make this point, thanks for saving me the (short)

Jul 11, 10:42am

It's just a list of senior QBs, no matter how good or bad,

Jul 11, 09:47am

I realize you missed the discussion last night. (nm)

Jul 11, 09:54am

Oh, yes I did ... sorry. (nm)

Jul 11, 10:28am

I excluded him because he had never started a game before

Jul 11, 10:41am

What is record with underclass QBs?

UteonBainbridge

Jul 11, 09:22am

Bosco helps that stat as he won a national title as a junior (nm)

BYUFam1

Jul 11, 09:44am

I have seen the record of Jr QB's, it is respectable (short)

Jericho

Jul 11, 10:15am

It would take some time to compile it, but definitely not as

Jul 11, 10:51am

Some of that work was already done....

BYUFam1

Jul 11, 10:58am

81% games won for Sr's vs 70% games won for Jr's (nm)

Jericho

Jul 11, 11:07am

And that was when these seniors were juniors, for the most

Jul 11, 11:10am

+1, most QB's start getting decent as Juniors

Jericho

Jul 11, 11:27am

I expect 2012 to be a lot like 1999, minus the conf champ (nm)

byutx

Jul 11, 09:45am

I like our chances with Nelson.

Jul 11, 09:45am

what about in seasons when the Sr. QB is starting the

Jul 11, 09:49am

I think RN's intangibles, locks and abs will balance out the

byutx

Jul 11, 09:53am

between USU and BYU, he's started plenty of games. (nm)

Jul 11, 10:04am

Great!! Good luck with that. (nm)

Jul 13, 01:55am

Didn't Doman first start partway into his Junior season? (nm)

Jul 11, 11:36am

you mean like what Doman did? (nm)

Jericho

Jul 11, 12:41pm

Sorry, won't happen for Riley

checoug

Jul 11, 11:29am

As they say though, past performance is no guarantee... (nm)

Jul 11, 11:41am

And for all those that believe it is, I have some stocks I'd (short)

Jul 11, 12:09pm

I am STOKED for this season! I believe some good things will (short)

BBLUE76

Jul 11, 12:00pm

No pressure Riley.... (nm)

Jul 11, 12:39pm

No kidding... (nm)

Jul 11, 08:53pm

Hope that didn't take

Jul 11, 12:42pm

Might be good to add Gary Sheide to the list Japan Coug,

Jul 11, 12:59pm

Yep, and Gif Neilson (nm)

Jul 11, 01:10pm

Unfortunately

Jul 11, 02:34pm

I thought about going further back, but ran out of time. (short)

Jul 11, 09:08pm

Not too much work. Wrubell must have read my post :) (nm)

Jul 11, 08:55pm

I thought it might have been

Jul 12, 11:37am

Correct, I hadn't seen it. Now I feel like a hack. (nm)

Jul 12, 05:10pm

No need

Jul 12, 07:46pm

Bosco was 2nd team QB his senior year and #3 in Heisman? (short)

Jul 11, 07:03pm

I think it might have been the Air Force QB, AFA was really

Jul 11, 09:02pm

Thanks for the info. (nm)

Jul 12, 01:56am

Nice stats but look beyond the "Senior" element

GA_Coug

Jul 11, 10:22pm

True, and I certainly don't expect Riley to perform at the

Jul 11, 10:26pm

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.