Don't tell me what the voters said. That is my point. You can only win the games you play. BYU didn't accomplish a single thing on the field that Utah didn't in 04 or 08. They both won every single one of their games. BYU can't claim that they beat a team ranked higher than someone Utah beat because that didn't happen.
In the end, they won the NC and that is something Utah didn't do. But that was directly related to something that neither team could control (whether or not other teams in the top 5 lost games). Am I saying something that is incorrect here?