Really a non-point, no one believes that we should land only 4/5 star kids.....that is fairy tale land. We should try to land top tier LDS talent that fits BYU. The rest will be 1-3 star athletes who the coaches see with upside.
I understand what you are saying in your post, but your earlier posts were talking in circles. Rankings are not the end all be all, but as a generalization there is some correlation with rating and future NFL prospects.