My Account
Sign up, and you'll be able to customize your font size and more!
Sign up
Report problem with this ad
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Jan 11, 2018
1:06
:26
pm
smokymountainrain
All-American
ah. thanks. glad to hear that's the argument, but i would argue they wouldn't
be as good as Alabama under that scenario. they would need to go undefeated in order to be considered "good enough".
but at least with your explanation it makes some sense. though it does come across as clickbaitish.
This message has been modified
Originally posted on Jan 11, 2018 at 1:06:26pm
Message modified by smokymountainrain on Jan 11, 2018 at 1:07:22pm
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Report problem with this ad
smokymountainrain
Previous username
travishansensucks
New username
smr
Bio page
smokymountainrain
Joined
Dec 14, 2006
Last login
Jul 3, 2019
Total posts
0 (0 FO)
Report problem with this ad
Messages
Author
Time
Article: Monson: Could Utah or BYU, even if they were good enough, win a football national championship? 50 bucks and a flawed system say no
View
[Salt Lake Tribune]
gmonson@sltrib.com twitterFollow @GordonMonson
1/11/18 12:25pm
Utah would 100% be in if 13-0. No discussion
Dissenter
1/11/18 12:26pm
like it's idiotic to say otherwise
Dissenter
1/11/18 12:26pm
Not necessarily. Especially with weak PAC-12 and weak OOC schedule.
Dangerous
1/11/18 12:29pm
sorry, let me rephrase. They'd've made all CFPs thus far if 13-0
Dissenter
1/11/18 12:30pm
Nah, an undefeated P5 Conference Champion gets in
WhiteKnight
1/11/18 12:30pm
like wisconsin this year. if wisconsin wins the Big 10 champ game, they were in
smokymountainrain
1/11/18 12:34pm
without question. i'm not going to read the article, but i can't believe monson
smokymountainrain
1/11/18 12:30pm
yeah, that's weird
SingleStrapBackpack
1/11/18 12:36pm
well, only sith's speak in absolutes, but yes i'd say it's like 98% certain a
nashty
1/11/18 12:36pm
Undefeated conference champ Utah would probably make the CFP, even if their
Martin Van Nostrand
1/11/18 12:29pm
the only way any undefeated P5 team doesn't make it is if there are four other
smokymountainrain
1/11/18 12:32pm
Why is this a discussion?
schofim
1/11/18 12:38pm
a guy named gordon monson wrote an article.
smokymountainrain
1/11/18 12:39pm
That headline says nothing about being unbeaten.
fulano
1/11/18 12:42pm
says "even if they were good enough" ---if not unbeaten, they aren't good enough
smokymountainrain
1/11/18 12:48pm
The article says if they were in Alabama's shoes (late loss, no Conf Champ game)
fulano
1/11/18 1:01pm
oh, so it's clickbait?
Dissenter
1/11/18 1:05pm
ah. thanks. glad to hear that's the argument, but i would argue they wouldn't
smokymountainrain
1/11/18 1:06pm
Alabama got in despite those bad points because they had a decade of history
byujag
1/11/18 2:02pm
A whole thread of people arguing a point that isn't in the article because everyone here refuses to read the Trib
YIsForBrigham
1/11/18 1:58pm
Monson - DON'T CLICK IT!
ArchbishopMitty
1/11/18 6:19pm
Report problem with this ad
Posting on CougarBoard
In order to post, you will need to either
sign up
or
log in
.
Report problem with this ad