We're not going anywhere but down until we start winning, and joining the MWC isn't going to change that.

Mar 12, 2018
4:38:42pm

BlueFever 3rd String

It makes the most sense to stay put. Independence is where BYU lives or dies.

This message has been modified

Originally posted on Mar 12, 2018 at 4:38:42pm

Message parent changed from http://www.cougarboard.com/board/message.html?id=19487755 to http://www.cougarboard.com/board/message.html?id=19487388 by on Mar 12, 2018 at 4:39:17pm

Report problem with this ad

BlueFever

Previous username: JerryAtric
Bio page: BlueFever
Joined: Sep 3, 2017
Last login: Apr 24, 2024
Total posts: 8,824 (24 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

I am now more than ever against joining the Mountain West in FB (edit to include NY6 argument)

ColonelMustard All-American

3/12/18 12:11am

It’s easy to know just how much everyone would hate being in the MWC based on how much everyone dislikes this year’s

YIsForBrigham

3/12/18 12:26am

Not true. As a member of the WAC we brought in #1 Miami, Penn State,

Cougarfan777

3/12/18 12:52am

The WAC was 20 years ago. Our schedules in the WAC have no bearing on today’s reality

YIsForBrigham

3/12/18 1:11am

It just depends on who you want to schedule. You look at years like 04'

Cougarfan777

3/12/18 1:20am

Here’s boise’s 2018 home schedule

YIsForBrigham

3/12/18 1:40am

The potential to go to an NY6 game is the only argument that makes sense that makes sense to me. The whole conference

ColonelMustard

3/12/18 1:19am

But my response to that is playing a crappy schedule for the opportunity to go to an NY6 bowl one every 20 years is not

ColonelMustard

3/12/18 1:25am

Serious question? Is this a crappy schedule?

Cougarfan777

3/12/18 1:29am

No. But we didn't have those kind of games every year. If we could get those kind of pre conference games every year

ColonelMustard

3/12/18 1:51am

I'm not sure I follow you. Is this a call to rejoin the WAC?

BlueFever

3/12/18 8:29am

It means that even when we were in the WAC we were able to bring the the most

Cougarfan777

3/12/18 8:45pm

I don't agree at all. College football is very different today than it use to be

SWP

3/13/18 8:30am

Why in the world do you think we'd consistently go 11-1? We rarely did it when

SWP

3/12/18 9:51am

We will be closer to 11-1 instead of 4-9, and we will be in a NY6 discussion as

Cougarfan777

3/12/18 8:49pm

You suggest 2-4 P5 games a year. We haven't been able to consistently win those

SWP

3/13/18 8:34am

Cougar777 at first I thought you were serious. Now I know you're just trolling.

Ned Schneebly

3/12/18 10:15am

I think Boise State is a better comparison than Utah state

mosterlow

3/12/18 1:28am

You make some good points. But would we really ever make it to a NY6 bowl that often? So for the 20 years we don't make

ColonelMustard

3/12/18 1:54am

Well Boise State at 11-2 made it, then Houston at 11-1, then western Michigan

mosterlow

3/12/18 2:01am

Maybe we were the top team before they opened up the bcs to non power teams. but since then we haven't been the top

ColonelMustard

3/12/18 2:06am

For years it was TCU, BYU, Utah, and Boise State

mosterlow

3/12/18 2:12am

ok. But what about recruiting though? Back then utah was with us in the mountain west. Now they are in the Pac 12. We

ColonelMustard

3/12/18 2:15am

In 10 years, Boise has played a total of 5 P5 games at home

YIsForBrigham

3/12/18 1:55am

I said they are a better comparison, and I see 5 in 5 years

mosterlow

3/12/18 2:09am

I understand what you’re saying and I would hope it’s true that we could get better games than Boise

YIsForBrigham

3/12/18 2:36am

Bingo

BYUButters

3/12/18 11:37am

Your point proves that G5 schools will NOT be able to schedule P5 schools like

BYUButters

3/12/18 11:38am

CBSSports is reason enough to stay out of the MWC for football.

IceCreamButt

3/12/18 2:05am

I’m excited about all of them. It’s BYU football. And we’re favored

canofpicante

3/12/18 12:20pm

If we could field Top 25 teams consistently

2FarGone

3/12/18 12:32am

And yet it's interesting that Utah, Boise St and TCU, along with others, have

BlueForLife

3/12/18 7:54am

you make good points. I guess I'm glad I don't have to make the decisions. If only we would have gotten into a P5 back

ColonelMustard

3/12/18 7:51pm

Man, it seemed like we were so close for a minute or two there. I let the rumors

BlueForLife

3/12/18 8:47pm

One problem I see is it just seems very unlikely that we will have the chance at

westsidecoug

3/12/18 8:16am

The current MWC is not the MWC BYU left. That bridge burned long ago.

SoCalCoug

3/12/18 10:10am

You're wrong about recruiting.

displacedute

3/12/18 12:49pm

We're not going anywhere but down until we start winning, and joining the MWC isn't going to change that.

BlueFever

3/12/18 4:38pm

It might.

displacedute

3/12/18 5:31pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad