May 26, 2018
11:33:25pm
11:33:25pm
My top ten.
Nielsen -1976 AA. Beat Utah. Tied for 1st wac. 1977 before getting hurt had 16 passing tds in 4 games. In CFB hall of fame since 1994.
Wilson
McMahon
Young
Boscoe
Detmer
Sark
Doman - He never lost to Utah. 2001 was the best offense I’ve ever seen at BYU. Threw for over 3500. Ran for over 800 (gross yds) He deserves to be on this list.
Beck
Hall
Hard to find a spot for Hill as a top 10 BYU QB.
I think Hill fits in with Walsh and Feterik.
Good, but not great.
Of the 3, Feterik is the only one that beat Utah.
All 3 QBs combined they were 1-6 against Utah. And never won an outright conference championship.
Walsh was the only one of the 3 to win a bowl game.
Nielsen -1976 AA. Beat Utah. Tied for 1st wac. 1977 before getting hurt had 16 passing tds in 4 games. In CFB hall of fame since 1994.
Wilson
McMahon
Young
Boscoe
Detmer
Sark
Doman - He never lost to Utah. 2001 was the best offense I’ve ever seen at BYU. Threw for over 3500. Ran for over 800 (gross yds) He deserves to be on this list.
Beck
Hall
Hard to find a spot for Hill as a top 10 BYU QB.
I think Hill fits in with Walsh and Feterik.
Good, but not great.
Of the 3, Feterik is the only one that beat Utah.
All 3 QBs combined they were 1-6 against Utah. And never won an outright conference championship.
Walsh was the only one of the 3 to win a bowl game.
- Previous username
- Azul_Rust
- Bio page
- Holy Driver
- Joined
- Oct 5, 2014
- Last login
- Apr 23, 2024
- Total posts
- 5,228 (545 FO)
Messages
Time
5/26/18 11:36pm
5/26/18 11:47pm
5/27/18 11:29am
Young was never the strongest lifter pound for pound like Taysom was in college and is in the NFL...
5/27/18 12:01am
5/28/18 5:22pm
5/27/18 11:50am
5/26/18 11:38pm
5/27/18 9:00pm