cannot figure out which is the right decision. Tanner has tremoundous experience and talent but some people with a lot more expereince at coaching than me have said Tanner is a STAR at pracitice but CANNOT deliver game day (defensive coordinators have a blue print how to rattle and shake him). Others say that to put a freshman in with this schedule could ruin him and his confiidence (and that Joe is more of a game manager than a QB to build your program around).