You can be taken more seriously by not being so black and white. Sports is not a "you're amazing or you suck" type of animal. That's not how it works. If you're not Lebron, it doesn't mean you suck. You can't just keep saying everyone out there sucks because they don't blow your mind.
Considering one has actually played, and was decent in his first year, in a system that sucked for everyone, and one hasn't done anything yet... I'd say hold off on calling one an upgrade.
At the least, it's an upgrade in depth, and that's what matters for BYU. We always have awful depth. I'll be happy if he becomes a solid bench role player. There's a chance both he and Hardnett both do for a while. That would be good news for us.