This is the biggest reason all movies from books are generally better

Sign up, and you can make all message times appear in your timezone. Sign up

Report problem with this ad

Jul 15, 2018
10:15:35pm

Nat Gas Man All-American

This is the biggest reason all movies from books are generally better

Report problem with this ad

Nat Gas Man

Previous username: TXSmith
Bio page: Nat Gas Man
Joined: Apr 28, 2010
Last login: Aug 23, 2023
Total posts: 53,749 (638 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

When you compare the writing of star wars and Harry Potter,

7/15/18 9:46pm

Why does no one want to direct it? and why do they want to quit?

7/15/18 9:48pm

Apparently they are changing directors and Kennedy is

7/15/18 9:56pm

She should have just let the director and creative teams do their thing

Crazy Duck

7/15/18 10:00pm

They already have a director. It’s jj abrams. They want to replace the head of Lucas film, Kathleen Kennedy, but no one

sgriff

7/15/18 10:04pm

But I don't think it was always Abrams. They fired someone.

7/15/18 10:05pm

Kennedy fired Colin Trevorrow (Director of Jurassic World)

Crazy Duck

7/15/18 10:07pm

True. I bet he’s kinda relieved now.

sgriff

7/15/18 10:09pm

The problem with SW is that it’s been over 40 years since the beginning and fans put it on a pedestal

IceBlueCoug

7/15/18 9:49pm

History judges

TNT

7/15/18 9:51pm

The other problem is Lucas. He had a great idea

7/15/18 9:52pm

Maybe the writing is tidy because it's from... books

Crush4

7/15/18 9:51pm

And the same person

Kerbouchard

7/15/18 10:00pm

This is the biggest reason all movies from books are generally better

Nat Gas Man

7/15/18 10:15pm

This is the most true statement on CB for ages.

UNHuskerCoug

7/15/18 10:40pm

SW is a Great universe with dumb stories

Mrs Featerbottom

7/15/18 9:53pm

That's kinda true.

7/15/18 9:54pm

Kinda my point with my post below.

Mrs Featerbottom

7/15/18 9:56pm

Hero of a Thousand Faces

TNT

7/15/18 9:54pm

I don't like eigher much, but at least star wars doen't put me to sleep quite as

Plato

7/15/18 9:54pm

I thought HP had waaaaaaaaay better character development than SW

Crazy Duck

7/15/18 10:02pm

It does for sure. But the first 3 sw movies did a much better

7/15/18 10:03pm

Oh I completely agree. This new series had so much potential too...

Crazy Duck

7/15/18 10:05pm

Problem with the newest SW characters is you dont care about them.

WJCougar

7/15/18 10:01pm

TLJ really killed the character development for everyone

Crazy Duck

7/15/18 10:03pm

True....you got an idea in Force Awakens....then TLJ did nothing with it.

WJCougar

7/15/18 10:06pm

Yep, you end up not caring at all if the new characters bite the dust

Crush4

7/15/18 10:03pm

I wouldn't have been sad if Finn died in that final scene of TLJ.

WJCougar

7/15/18 10:08pm

And *spoiler alert A* turned into a real *spolier alert B*

Gil Buckman

7/15/18 10:17pm

No need for spoiler alerts with Star Wars.

WJCougar

7/15/18 10:23pm

Lucas had one of the greatest & absolutely

Downtown

7/15/18 10:24pm

Lucas didn't throw anything away, he sold it for over $4 Billion. Disney's going to come out in the black too.

Bert609

7/16/18 6:32am

I’m talking 1997 when he started “fixing” the originals

Downtown

7/16/18 9:21pm

I am a huge Harry Potter fan but the writing is anything but neat and tidy.

RalphWiggam

7/15/18 11:15pm

I think that's part of the point. Re-reading (listening?) to the HP audio-books with my kids and Rowlings

Bert609

7/16/18 6:33am

SW movies >>> HP movies

Gorum the Old

7/16/18 7:42am

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad