I think Mangum deserves a shot with a new offense. Ty's offense sucked even with

Sign up, and you'll be able to vote in polls. Sign up

Report problem with this ad

Aug 9, 2018
9:38:33am

Windward_Coug All-American

I think Mangum deserves a shot with a new offense. Ty's offense sucked even with

an all-time great RB AND QB in the backfield. I'd be really hesitant to throw a true freshman out there with our opening schedule, you may shatter his confidence and ruin him. If Mangum still looks lost and isn't performing after the first five games then have Critchlow take over and use Wilson only if you absolutely have to.

Report problem with this ad

Windward_Coug

Previous username: Eldoradocoug
Bio page: Windward_Coug
Joined: Feb 8, 2011
Last login: Apr 18, 2024
Total posts: 10,054 (26 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

I've been pulling for Mangum, but I'm officially onboard the Wilson train now.

8/9/18 8:59am

"We know what we get from Mangum"? Really?

Indy Coug

8/9/18 9:01am

I think the problem is the exact opposite.

Ssebo

8/9/18 9:16am

I want to see Mangum in Grimes' offense first

GoFish

8/9/18 9:02am

I take this approach

Heinz57

8/9/18 9:02am

That fact makes it so surprising to me to see kids transfer so quickly. Your

crack

8/9/18 9:06am

Especially with BYU the past few years...

jcase16byu

8/9/18 11:40am

Agree

y over u

8/9/18 9:04am

Whoever is 2nd string will likely start the last 9 games anyway.

OPINIONS

8/9/18 9:06am

Games 3 and 5 on the schedule are brutal. Games 1 and 2 are not brutal

cwilke1

8/9/18 9:13am

Mangum is going to start

2FarGone

8/9/18 9:25am

If he’s going on a mission...then give his reps to someone who will be

kotacoug

8/9/18 9:07am

He isn't a mission kid

Backcountry

8/9/18 9:23am

I think Wilson is taking the Mcmahon route.

8/9/18 9:40am

Start the senior. Have the true freshman ready.

8/9/18 9:08am

Historically, a few true freshman QBs have started in game 1 and played well

ColoSpgs

8/9/18 9:08am

Didn't read past your title, but I don't care who starts. I just want to win, or

OneUpper

8/9/18 9:10am

We've had one week of fall camp with no pads.

8/9/18 9:12am

And most of CB has seen nothing of it but a few highlight clips and

8/9/18 9:17am

"We will be teetering on 6-6 if we're lucky" with Mangum?

Backcountry

8/9/18 9:22am

We were competitive against the U last year with our worst team in 30 years

cwilke1

8/9/18 9:28am

Not really

Backcountry

8/9/18 9:35am

I agree Utah outplayed us. But if a team has the ball at the end of the game

cwilke1

8/9/18 9:49am

Byu was not competitive. Sorry.

Backcountry

8/9/18 10:06am

They held Utah to under 20 points and were 1 TD away from winning.

Gorum the Old

8/9/18 12:39pm

Doesn't matter who the QB is, it's not going to be a "special season"

Byu_1988

8/9/18 9:29am

<< Deleted >>

East1999

8/9/18 9:30am

I disagree.

Hawk Talons

8/9/18 9:35am

I think Mangum deserves a shot with a new offense. Ty's offense sucked even with

8/9/18 9:38am

We don't know what we get

shakarocks

8/9/18 9:39am

The worst thing you could do for Wilson is to start him against Arizona

2FarGone

8/9/18 9:40am

If that destroys Wilson forever, I don't want him anyway.

SandYFan

8/9/18 10:00am

Signed Jake Fromm

8/9/18 10:08am

This is laughable

8/9/18 9:59am

Is this a Covey/Detmer situation?

TunaNoCrust

8/9/18 10:14am

Based on what? A few minutes of practice tweeted by the media?

Refugee

8/9/18 10:57am

Ty sucked his first game against Wyoming and he was a redshirt freshman. Start

coolblue

8/9/18 11:03am

He can play the last 4 games and not lose a year.

TunaNoCrust

8/9/18 11:29am

Considering nobody has seen Wilson play with pads on, this is ridiculous.

Machiavelli

8/9/18 11:19am

So why are the coaches reportedly still undecided? Coaches are putting up smoke

8/9/18 11:28am

Saturday will be a full speed, pads on practice..

Machiavelli

8/9/18 11:44am

Yeah, that makes sense. You're prob right. I sure wish Mangum was a Junior.

8/9/18 11:52am

I'm just hoping Mangum can show that he can be dominant

Machiavelli

8/9/18 12:06pm

Because they have no reason to let the cat out of the bag

shakarocks

8/9/18 12:46pm

during all of spring practice, the QBs were live.

Bostonblue

8/9/18 11:32am

Premature pick. Wait till the pads go on.

BurbankCoug

8/9/18 12:10pm

ZW has played without full pads and without facing a full speed defense.

OBXCougar

8/9/18 12:22pm

I was gonna ask how much mangum regrets taking the snap against MSU... then I

Powerbait DPM studnt

8/9/18 1:11pm

I agree, we have seen Tanner, let's focus on the future.

Catman

8/9/18 1:29pm

You've seen Tanner in TD's atrocious offense.

Machiavelli

8/9/18 1:31pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad