Interesting comment by Harmon about the scrimmage.

Aug 12, 2018
9:44:27am

kC Cougar All-American

“Anybody who has a favorite in the QB derby would have left that scrimmage believing their favorite guy had the good day.”

DeseretNews.com

With quarterbacks under intense scrutiny, BYU's offense developing day by day this fall

Tanner Mangum and Zach Wilson have been given the majority of the practice reps but Joe Critchlow is proving to be a steady, poised challenger for BYU's starting QB job at Arizona. Here's a look at the tapestry of what's going behind the scenes.

https://www.deseretnews.com/article/900027895/with-quarterbacks-under-intense-scrutiny-byus-offense-developing-day-by-day-this-fall.html

This message has been modified

Originally posted on Aug 12, 2018 at 9:44:27am

Message modified by kC Cougar on Aug 12, 2018 at 9:47:17am

Report problem with this ad

kC Cougar

Bio page: kC Cougar
Joined: Jul 22, 2005
Last login: Apr 24, 2024
Total posts: 4,187 (240 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Interesting comment by Harmon about the scrimmage.

kC Cougar

8/12/18 9:44am

I hate hearing things like this.

rad dawg

8/12/18 9:46am

Dick is trying to play peacemaker. I was there and it would be impossible to not

YbeatsU

8/12/18 9:48am

Which ones?

Non-mo Coug

8/12/18 9:49am

Tanner didn't. Zach did

Heinz57

8/12/18 9:52am

Can’t say or it will go away but 1 QB threw 3 TD passes and the other QB only

YbeatsU

8/12/18 9:53am

Who was playing defense? What defenses were being run against each guy?

StantonMac

8/12/18 9:56am

Both had multiple drives against the 1st and 2nd Defense.

YbeatsU

8/12/18 9:59am

Don't hold out on us! We want to know the details!

TheLoneCougar

8/12/18 9:51am

Yes, please don’t post teasers like this

cougarfann888

8/12/18 9:52am

He already posted about it and it was removed

GOR

8/12/18 10:00am

I was not there but know people who were there

kC Cougar

8/12/18 9:54am

Not difficult

Heinz57

8/12/18 9:58am

And we are supposed to tell that from reports from 1 closed scrimmage in Aug?

rggee

8/12/18 9:59am

Look at the pattern of 2017, need more proof?

Heinz57

8/12/18 10:00am

Apples and oranges. Plus tanner scored a lot more TDs in college in 2017 than

rggee

8/12/18 10:02am

4-9 result based

Heinz57

8/12/18 10:06am

I hope so. Impossible to know at this point.

rggee

8/12/18 10:07am

Did you say the point of the QB is to lead the team to score TDs?

TheLoneCougar

8/12/18 5:56pm

Correct and since Tanner was 4-9 in 2017 the answer is no

Heinz57

8/12/18 9:16pm

Wrong

kC Cougar

8/12/18 10:00am

Ok. QB 1 had 0 picks as well.

YbeatsU

8/12/18 10:03am

CHECK MATE

GOR

8/12/18 10:05am

Not just talking about picks

kC Cougar

8/12/18 10:07am

Does the other team get points for potential turnovers?

Blue for Life

8/12/18 12:53pm

Well if a CB likes one QB more than another, they can make a potential INT, out

viper

8/12/18 5:38pm

Why can't we talk about how each did in the scrimmage?

Stucoug83

8/12/18 3:51pm

Appreciate your post and insight, please keep it coming

ColoSpgs

8/12/18 10:00am

Exactly. Let's leave the decision up to the qualified guys that are actually in

rggee

8/12/18 10:05am

Duh, coaches make the final decision...

Heinz57

8/12/18 10:08am

Who would that be?

coolblue

8/12/18 5:54pm

wilson beat a senior IMO from what was reported

Y4LYFE

8/12/18 10:46am

Wilson beat Defense A in a controlled scrimmage more times than Mangum beat Defense B

ColoSpgs

8/12/18 11:15am

QB main goal is to lead a team to produce TD's

Heinz57

8/12/18 9:52am

What if a QB leads the team to more TD’s but

kC Cougar

8/12/18 9:59am

RE: What if a QB leads the team to more TD’s but

Heinz57

8/12/18 10:05am

Not talking about touchdowns vs field goals

kC Cougar

8/12/18 10:15am

BYU is to this point

Heinz57

8/12/18 9:13pm

1280 was talking about this on Friday. Do you pull you’re QB who is scoring a lot, but

Holy Driver

8/12/18 10:05am

I slightly disagree. I believe the main goal is to lead the team to victory

eyebleedblu

8/12/18 10:19am

This 2018 team has to produce TD in order to win, just watch

Heinz57

8/12/18 9:15pm

Anyone else concerned by The section where it talks about 11v11?

Sweetness

8/12/18 10:46am

Maybe it’s a change brought on by the new coaches?

Holy Driver

8/12/18 10:52am

Based on comments from grimes it sounded like this was kalani driven.

Sweetness

8/12/18 11:31am

No..

TheLost

8/12/18 12:28pm

Maybe it’s what was missing last year

antiyewt

8/12/18 1:57pm

Everyone ignored my post about this haha nice to see it generated some discussio

BYUFootballisBack

8/12/18 11:20am

LOL at those who think there's some kind of separation

With quarterbacks under intense scrutiny, BYU's offense developing day by day this fall

Posting on CougarBoard