My Account
Sign up, and you'll be able to vote in polls.
Sign up
Report problem with this ad
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Aug 12, 2018
2:32
:17
pm
WhiteKnight
All-American
Luke without a second thought
If Luke got as many touches as Harvey, that rushing record wouldn't be close. Luke had over 1500 in ONE season. A healthy Luke Staley is second to no one in BYU history.
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Report problem with this ad
WhiteKnight
New username
The Dark Knight
Bio page
WhiteKnight
Joined
Oct 28, 2004
Last login
Mar 29, 2019
Total posts
0 (0 FO)
Report problem with this ad
Messages
Author
Time
Harvey Unga vs. Jamaal Williams vs. Luke Staley
prcoug
8/12/18 2:29pm
Luke, and it’s not really close.
conflictedcoug
8/12/18 2:30pm
Reasoning? Seemed wonder how others would do with Luke's o-line?
prcoug
8/12/18 2:31pm
A healthy Luke was head and shoulders better.
Metallicat
8/12/18 2:35pm
Speed, power, size, catching ability
conflictedcoug
8/12/18 2:39pm
He’s conflicted.
pt crasher
8/12/18 4:05pm
He had one great year. One. Jamaal and Harvey had better
Jdoc
8/12/18 2:38pm
*because of injury
conflictedcoug
8/12/18 2:39pm
Agreed, but I don’t think you can say he was the
Jdoc
8/12/18 2:41pm
The question was who would I like to see
conflictedcoug
8/12/18 2:45pm
RE: He had one great year. One. Jamaal and Harvey had better
Northern Blue
8/12/18 4:49pm
I agree he was the most talented, but he couldn’t stay on the fields save his
Jdoc
8/12/18 6:20pm
That's why I specified, Junior Year Luke Staley
WhiteKnight
8/12/18 6:43pm
Luke without a second thought
WhiteKnight
8/12/18 2:32pm
But he wasn’t healthy. You can’t play the what if game.
Jdoc
8/12/18 2:34pm
Ok, Doak Walker Trophy 2001. There's an accomplishment for you.
dreamlvr
8/12/18 3:21pm
And, I might add, it was very well deserved. He was the best back in the whole
dreamlvr
8/12/18 3:24pm
Years? He was healthy one year. Listen, I would take
Jdoc
8/12/18 3:25pm
That a guy with that much talent had such terrible knees and ankles was the
dreamlvr
8/12/18 3:33pm
It really is unfortunate. He was an amazing talent.
Jdoc
8/12/18 3:36pm
Jamaal. He played against much tougher opponents than Luke ever did.
Richbyu
8/12/18 2:35pm
Plus he shared the backfield with Taysom.
BYihateU
8/12/18 3:10pm
I don't think there's a wrong choice between Jamaal and Luke. I'd take either before Harvey.
SpiffCoug
8/12/18 2:43pm
Harvey was amazing strength and speed/ shiftiness. Would have the record
claw
8/12/18 2:45pm
JW>LS>HU.
Holy Driver
8/12/18 2:52pm
Assuming the injuries, off the field issues, etc all remained: H > L > J
Wedgetail
8/12/18 3:39pm
Luke, no question
zerome4sooners
8/12/18 3:42pm
Luke Staley was incredible.
Heath Squashwell
8/12/18 3:44pm
Luke was great but the chance of him finishing a season would be nearly zero
HighHorse
8/12/18 4:06pm
Harvey was a threat for a good gain each play
Dan
8/12/18 4:22pm
I'd go with Jamaal. So consistent. Staley was amazing, but that was just one yr.
sportsbro
8/12/18 4:48pm
Love all. I'd go Luke, Unga & Williams. Jamaal is the only one to play 4 years.
Benfica1
8/12/18 4:52pm
Jamaal, Luke, Unga
D.T. Survivor
8/12/18 6:34pm
Harvey...4 year Harvey.
Kama'aina
8/12/18 6:42pm
I wish we could have seen 1 more year for HU, he was unstoppable
pegushin
8/12/18 7:31pm
You could make a good case for any one of the 3
CougarsFanSince80s
8/12/18 7:30pm
Agree on being able to make a case for any of them
D.T. Survivor
8/12/18 8:28pm
To anyone who actually watched Luke Staley play, this is an easy question.
Ham
8/12/18 9:08pm
I watched Staley play and based on Jamaal’s sr year, I give him the edge
D.T. Survivor
8/12/18 9:18pm
Report problem with this ad
Posting on CougarBoard
In order to post, you will need to either
sign up
or
log in
.
Report problem with this ad