My Account
Sign up, and you'll be able to vote in polls.
Sign up
Report problem with this ad
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Sep 15, 2018
7:54
:46
pm
Goliath
All-American
Sure looked to me like he caught it cleanly, controlled the ball, and didn't
lose it until he tried to tuck it in. I don't know the rule in college for what constitutes a catch, but he definitely had control before he tried to tuck it.
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Report problem with this ad
Goliath
Previous username
Koolio
Bio page
Goliath
Joined
May 25, 2005
Last login
Mar 23, 2024
Total posts
30,227 (1,748 FO)
Report problem with this ad
Messages
Author
Time
POLL: Was the pass to Holker at the end of the 2nd Q a completion?
Jericho
9/15/18 7:52pm
No, they overturned it.
TriggerWarning
9/15/18 7:53pm
Catch and fumble, fumble recovery.
SDcookie
9/15/18 7:54pm
Nah he didnt have it long enough to be a catch
rggee
9/15/18 7:54pm
Looked to me like he had 2 steps before it came loose. But I'm not surprised it was ruled incomplete based on how these
SDcookie
9/15/18 7:58pm
he never secured it in the first place
SingleStrapBackpack
9/15/18 8:05pm
Blam my blue goggles. I was so pumped after that play, despite the O PI on the play, I really wanted that play.
SDcookie
9/15/18 8:12pm
Oh, I did too. Watching it live it 100% looked like a catch and I was stoked. Really too big he couldn't complete it.
SingleStrapBackpack
9/15/18 8:23pm
Definitely not. Didn't perform an act common to the game
2018grad
9/15/18 7:55pm
I’m 50/50
BigYfan
9/15/18 7:54pm
Sure looked to me like he caught it cleanly, controlled the ball, and didn't
Goliath
9/15/18 7:54pm
Need to hold it long enough to perform "an act common to the game" Tucking the
2018grad
9/15/18 7:57pm
I’m blue goggled, but no way that should be a completion. I would have
cougaman
9/15/18 7:55pm
yes, only because the replay could not show he did not have possession during
Pretorian
9/15/18 7:57pm
All I know is had that been Wisconsin they wouldn't have had enough "evidence"
Ernie
9/15/18 8:10pm
It would have been if Bushman had ran the route.
thecthdox
9/15/18 8:11pm
Report problem with this ad
Posting on CougarBoard
In order to post, you will need to either
sign up
or
log in
.
Report problem with this ad