Based on the schedule I don't see why not. We have played mostly decent

Sep 23, 2018
9:39:27am

BeardedSpock All-American

teams, unlike most ranked teams who have fattened up on G5/FCS competition.

Saturday's game will show if we really deserve the ranking.

Report problem with this ad

BeardedSpock

Bio page: BeardedSpock
Joined: Oct 10, 2013
Last login: Nov 29, 2023
Total posts: 5,791 (0 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

POLL: Do you think BYU is a legitimate top 25 team?

StantonMac Monkey see monkey do

9/23/18 9:11am

If they play UW tough (win or not), I may change my vote. Right now, I don't think so.

LiveCoug

9/23/18 9:12am

They are as legitimate as any other Top 25 team right now.

Junior Deputy

9/23/18 9:13am

If your in the top 25 your a legitimate top 25 team.

Blueto

9/23/18 9:13am

Last year is living in our heads rent free.

Probable Sacko

9/23/18 9:14am

I’m making mine pay the rent.

BeefNoodleCoug

9/23/18 9:17am

Right now they have a top 25 resume. No team has a better win and most teams

Mr. Scoobs

9/23/18 9:15am

Where is the I’m not sure and rankings shouldn’t be issued until week 8?

specsauce

9/23/18 9:16am

I think we deserve the ranking but I don’t believe we have the 25th best college

N8Dawg

9/23/18 9:18am

Based on the resume, yes. Do I think they are one of the 25 best teams right now

Martin Van Nostrand

9/23/18 9:18am

This is a fair assessment.

LiveCoug

9/23/18 9:19am

We are not one of the 25 best teams in the country but neither are a lot of

Cabadapeste

9/23/18 9:21am

I certainly don't think they're illegitimate. That would be an honor code violation.

jdub

9/23/18 9:23am

What does their parents' marital status have to do with their adherence to the

LeftOfNormal

9/23/18 9:53am

Rankings are about do you deserve to be top 25. In that sense, yes BYU is a top

Mark320

9/23/18 9:25am

BC of the line. But next week we will know. Get healthy Squally.

Dr MoBYU

9/23/18 9:25am

They aren't one of the 25 best teams in the country, but I'll happily celebrate them being voted that way

Indy Coug

9/23/18 9:31am

I’d like to know the 25 teams who you think have a better resume.

Mr. Scoobs

9/23/18 9:34am

We have a top 25 defense and run game.

BostonCougar

9/23/18 9:39am

Based on the schedule I don't see why not. We have played mostly decent

BeardedSpock

9/23/18 9:39am

Based on actual accomplishment on the field, yes, BYU is a legit top 25 team. BYU hasn't been given any benefit of the

CalGTR

9/23/18 10:30am

Agree

Posting on CougarBoard