Oct 10, 2018
9:02:07am
9:02:07am
Zach Wilson is not the answer. BYU’s problem is coaching.
And players can’t overcome poor coaching.
When Taysom went down to injury in 2014, Christian Stewart, a guy who was talked into joining the team, took over. He lost 4 straight games and won 4 straight. He looked good and led the team well. He looked far better than Tanner or Taysom ever did under Sitake.
When Taysom was injured in 2015, Anae took a fresh off his mission Tanner and made him a Freshman all-American.
Now, that Freshman All-American has regressed to a very poor QB. Last year, we went through 4 quarterbacks who couldn’t do the job.
So, I don’t believe Zach is the panacea we want him to be.
I believe Zach should start because of Tanner’s performance. If he has success, it will be in spite of coaching.
When Taysom went down to injury in 2014, Christian Stewart, a guy who was talked into joining the team, took over. He lost 4 straight games and won 4 straight. He looked good and led the team well. He looked far better than Tanner or Taysom ever did under Sitake.
When Taysom was injured in 2015, Anae took a fresh off his mission Tanner and made him a Freshman all-American.
Now, that Freshman All-American has regressed to a very poor QB. Last year, we went through 4 quarterbacks who couldn’t do the job.
So, I don’t believe Zach is the panacea we want him to be.
I believe Zach should start because of Tanner’s performance. If he has success, it will be in spite of coaching.
- Bio page
- Brigham
- Joined
- Jul 6, 2001
- Last login
- Apr 19, 2024
- Total posts
- 22,836 (6 FO)
Fans need to come around to the idea that the BYU O struggles due to QB limitations. It is the #1 issue since 2017. (Turnpike Lane, Oct 10, 2018 at 10:02am)
I agree that coaching is a huge problem... but the worst of coaches can’t hold some players back. Think Baker Mayfield (46in96, Oct 10, 2018 at 9:30am)
Other Related Threads:
I think its perfectly reasonable to compare a true freshman with about 5-6 (cougaman, Oct 10, 2018 at 10:55am)
Messages
Time
10/10/18 9:02am
10/10/18 9:07am
10/10/18 10:25am
10/10/18 9:06am
10/10/18 9:09am
The problems are not mutually exclusive. It’s not an either or problem. It’s both coaching and QB play... if at least
10/10/18 9:14am
10/10/18 9:16am
I agree that coaching is a huge problem... but the worst of coaches can’t hold some players back. Think Baker Mayfield
10/10/18 9:29am
10/10/18 9:48am
10/10/18 10:21am
10/10/18 9:18am
10/10/18 11:15am
10/10/18 11:24am
10/10/18 2:15pm
10/10/18 1:26pm
10/11/18 10:38am