No Jay Hill?

Sign up, and you can make all message times appear in your timezone. Sign up

Report problem with this ad

Oct 10, 2018
12:49:48pm

Randall Toomey Walk-on

No Jay Hill?

Report problem with this ad

Randall Toomey

Bio page: Randall Toomey
Joined: Aug 24, 2018
Last login: Jul 29, 2021
Total posts: 2,054 (3 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Kalani's replacement

BYU313

10/10/18 12:42pm

Was not happy when Bronco left, still a bronco fan and watch/cheer Virginia/Navy

stealth

10/10/18 12:46pm

Jay Hill, Robert Anae, Ken Niumatalolo, Darrell Bevell, Lance Anderson, Ed Lamb

4mack

10/10/18 12:46pm

I don't rule out Ed Lamb in the future but he should be crossed off for now.

10/10/18 12:49pm

So, 2005 would you have crossed Bronco off the list?

CougarThug

10/10/18 5:28pm

No, Bronco's defenses were fun to watch and performed well when he was under

10/10/18 5:35pm

Is Lamb LDS? I thought he wasn't.

displacedute

10/10/18 5:30pm

He is not.

demon_llama

10/10/18 8:02pm

Ed Lamb can't even get the right number of players on the field.

byubyu

10/10/18 12:52pm

truth. and more than once this year

kansascougar

10/10/18 12:53pm

Of all we've seen from our coaches over the last season and a half

10/10/18 12:54pm

I doubt Niumatalolo will be eager to come back for another interview

Byu_1988

10/10/18 1:33pm

I 100% agree with Anae.

BYU313

10/10/18 1:45pm

Not a popular thing to say on CB but I agree. I have been saying Anae would be

pappabear246

10/10/18 8:58pm

Ed Lamb isn’t a member of the Church. So they’d have to change the rule

mitchwhite221

10/10/18 2:37pm

I thought he was a convert ...but i could be wrong

4mack

10/10/18 2:39pm

Not a member.

Cougstreak

10/10/18 2:41pm

He’s not a member but his wife is

SouthernBlueBlood

10/10/18 2:41pm

first female head coach? and then have ed lamb telling her what to do

Powerbait DPM studnt

10/10/18 3:31pm

Ed Lamb isn't a member

CharlottesvilleCoug

10/10/18 7:47pm

Darrell Bevell after Andy Reid turns us down...but ya gotta try

Borg

10/10/18 12:48pm

If we get Nelsons support than anything is realistic

BYU313

10/10/18 1:10pm

If you are looking for realistic and experienced candidates they are in very

mudpupper

10/10/18 12:49pm

No Jay Hill?

10/10/18 12:49pm

I think the only realistic options are Jay Hill, Ken Niumatalolo, or UVA assit.

Richbyu

10/10/18 12:51pm

I guess if you throw Peterson in then Hill would be a candidate as well

mudpupper

10/10/18 12:51pm

Here is Jay Hill's record as a HC:

Richbyu

10/10/18 12:53pm

I think Bevell is realistic at the moment, he doesn't have a job and won't have

pinolero

10/10/18 12:59pm

^^^This, this, and this. Agree on all 3.

BYUHgrad

10/11/18 5:59pm

I really like Ken or even Anae.

BYU313

10/10/18 1:17pm

Being Poly may be a small advantage, but winning is the best advantage.

Return of the Yeti

10/10/18 2:10pm

Agreed

BYU313

10/10/18 2:49pm

<< Deleted >>

Return of the Yeti

10/10/18 2:12pm

Utah pretty much has Stanford figured out... I don't know about Lance Anderson

EEcougar

10/10/18 12:53pm

He has me intrigued right now. I'm trying to learn more about him.

mudpupper

10/10/18 12:57pm

A very good recruiter. Would probably hand the reigns to Grimes and manage the D

BYUHgrad

10/11/18 11:19pm

This whole question shows the predicament that the BYU AD has with regards to

mudpupper

10/10/18 12:55pm

Do we have to run the option if Ken comes?

BYU313

10/10/18 1:42pm

How many more years of 100+ ranked offenses until fans are okay with the option?

BYU Fan

10/10/18 4:39pm

This is why Holmoe shoud have fought to keep Bronco

Coogar2

10/10/18 7:55pm

Why? So they could at best just stay exactly as they were, and potentially

10/11/18 4:32pm

Disagree. A change was needed...for both parties involved.

BYUHgrad

10/11/18 11:20pm

If Kalani ends season 9-3 8-4 7-5 I say keep him because he’s not getting fired. Even if he loses to Utah

SouthernBlueBlood

10/10/18 12:59pm

Any of those gets us a bowl bid, so does the outcome of that game matter to you?

BYU313

10/10/18 1:14pm

No

SouthernBlueBlood

10/10/18 1:21pm

I agree with 8-4 or 9-3 but 7-5 seems a little lacking

BYU313

10/10/18 1:38pm

I shouldn’t say I don’t care but BYU won’t change at that record

SouthernBlueBlood

10/10/18 1:45pm

Dennis Pitta

roarcougar84

10/10/18 1:10pm

What if BYU stuns Boise on the smurf turf, but we still lose to Utah?

The Lone Star Cougar

10/10/18 1:10pm

If he wins the bowl game after that then no.

BYU313

10/10/18 1:12pm

There is no likely replacement available that I would consider an upgrade

10/10/18 1:14pm

That's sad, but I'm worried it's true

BYU313

10/10/18 1:15pm

Bevell. We need offense really bad.

mwcoug

10/10/18 1:30pm

He's a pro. Do we want pro-style?

TailgateU

10/10/18 1:35pm

Well my first choice will always be Mike Leach, but that's even more of a

mwcoug

10/10/18 1:38pm

I would love it if we got Leach.

Orem58thBall

10/10/18 1:57pm

Agreed on both accounts

BYU313

10/10/18 2:00pm

Maybe not a seismic shift. Who are his ministering bros? Get on it!

TailgateU

10/10/18 7:08pm

I once read on the board that Steve Sarkisian could be a possibility.

Powerbait DPM studnt

10/10/18 1:48pm

I thought he wasn't a member?

BYU313

10/10/18 1:50pm

He's not a member.

The Lone Star Cougar

10/10/18 1:53pm

Curious on the views of KW as a successor?

Cougstreak

10/10/18 1:55pm

If he helps us become better than Utah...

Powerbait DPM studnt

10/10/18 1:56pm

KW is not a great coach, he is better than Sitake though

BYU313

10/10/18 1:59pm

<< Deleted >>

trjohnson007

10/10/18 2:21pm

RE: KW is a great coach! UU was 1 win over CO away from PAC Champ Game in 15.

BYU313

10/10/18 2:44pm

He is a good coach and I think he’s a solid option

D.T. Survivor

10/10/18 9:10pm

I dislike this post for so many reasons but am too tired to elaborate. You just

Nagurski

10/10/18 2:11pm

...ok

BYU313

10/10/18 2:54pm

what if you went after Morgan Scalley? a HC job might persuade him to come here

Return of the Yeti

10/10/18 2:13pm

I think that's a possibility

BYU313

10/10/18 3:39pm

You love Bronco, but expect KS to beat Utah? That doesn't make sense.

Bostonblue

10/10/18 2:16pm

Come again?

Nagurski

10/10/18 2:18pm

sorry. I meant to respond to the OP. I've moved it now.

Bostonblue

10/10/18 2:25pm

Let me clarify

BYU313

10/10/18 2:41pm

So, you didn't like Bronco. Got it.

Bostonblue

10/10/18 3:27pm

I think you can still like a coach

BYU313

10/10/18 3:38pm

Ken Nuimatalolo will be the next BYU head coach.

GeraldGarner

10/10/18 3:12pm

Add it that I think he will be vested

cougswin

10/10/18 3:22pm

I heard that he only had to stick with navy for a few more years to get his

Powerbait DPM studnt

10/10/18 3:35pm

Ya, Kenny's coming, after turning down byu the first time, because he wants

Bluegoogles

10/10/18 4:48pm

Depends...

CougarThug

10/10/18 6:11pm

I hope you are right. He would be my favorite candidate

BYU313

10/10/18 3:26pm

Nah

shakarocks

10/10/18 3:56pm

I would love if he would come as HC but let an OC run the offense completely.

crack

10/10/18 4:22pm

So you are saying we have a chance...Bevell

Cougarpride

10/10/18 4:30pm

I love to laugh at all the "fire Kalani" crowd as they don't have a clue who

Bluegoogles

10/10/18 4:43pm

When at BYU, I wrote a paper arguing that Bronco should not be fired.

Powerbait DPM studnt

10/10/18 4:53pm

Did you discuss in your paper that Bronco wasn’t actually fired but

Traveshamockery

10/10/18 4:56pm

this was in 2015, so before he left... maybe it was my paper that drove him away

Powerbait DPM studnt

10/10/18 5:17pm

noone cares, but here's the paper i wrote

Powerbait DPM studnt

10/10/18 5:24pm

No I agree with you

BYU313

10/10/18 5:21pm

#justfirekalani. #crowtonwasbetter

Coogar2

10/10/18 8:01pm

What is the polar opposite for POTD? That is what this is.

UNHuskerCoug

10/10/18 4:53pm

Why do you say that?

BYU313

10/10/18 5:23pm

I say that because we are in no need of replacing

UNHuskerCoug

10/10/18 6:43pm

Ok I can respect that.

BYU313

10/10/18 11:10pm

I happen to believe that old saying, It’s not the Xs and Os,

UNHuskerCoug

10/11/18 9:32am

I can't argue with anything in that secoond paragraph, except about our RB's

BYU313

10/11/18 1:08pm

Nebraska has fired three coaches in the last 5 years and is now

deljdc

10/10/18 4:57pm

So are there really no good options for BYU?

BYU313

10/10/18 5:25pm

There is no silver bullet.

deljdc

10/11/18 6:57am

Do we need a silver bullet to beat Utah state?

BYU313

10/11/18 1:12pm

The gap between BYU and Utah State has not been very big

deljdc

10/12/18 7:22am

Do you think that gap is smaller becuase USU is better? or BYU is worse?

BYU313

10/12/18 11:02am

The question is not directed at me, but it is both.

Cougstreak

10/12/18 11:40am

Yeah that's what I would say too. Which I think could be attributted to coaching

BYU313

10/12/18 6:55pm

I see it as both

deljdc

10/12/18 7:33pm

While I liked Anae’s Offensive production, I don’t think he has the temperament

Bryceo19

10/10/18 5:03pm

Here's every member coach that I know of (head, coordinator, position, FCS, etc)

displacedute

10/10/18 5:59pm

Wow thank you, that is an awesome list. This is exactly what I wanted

BYU313

10/10/18 6:05pm

For solid head coaches, it’s a very short supply

D.T. Survivor

10/10/18 6:47pm

Yeah Gary Patterson is not of the schools faith which I believe is a requirement

BallisLife

10/10/18 7:03pm

He is a member.

Cougstreak

10/10/18 8:17pm

Ever hear of Ty Freakin’ Detmer?

UMWolverine

10/10/18 7:59pm

You're right, he's a candidate.

displacedute

10/11/18 10:42am

Being a member isn't the only criteria, as they must be a card carrying member

Bluegoogles

10/11/18 7:46am

Yes, I know.

displacedute

10/11/18 10:42am

That is a very good list

kimdaddy35

10/11/18 12:25pm

Thanks.

displacedute

10/11/18 12:31pm

I don’t hear Mike Leach’s name mentioned as a realistic option

D.T. Survivor

10/10/18 6:48pm

PAC$$>BYU $ and I believe he has to be living a higher mormon law than he does

BallisLife

10/10/18 7:04pm

Haha, you mean like Giving up the booze?

pappabear246

10/11/18 10:41am

You say “realistic option” and wonder why he is not included?

Cougstreak

10/10/18 8:15pm

What box doesn’t he check? Latter Day Saint, great HC experience,

D.T. Survivor

10/10/18 10:54pm

Yet, not realistic. No way he comes to BYU, not a fit for both parties.

Cougstreak

10/11/18 4:03am

I would give my right arm to get Leach as

pappabear246

10/11/18 10:39am

haha, beat Wisconsin on the road... then 2 weeks later people want him fired

Hill4Heisman

10/10/18 7:00pm

Getting dominated in Lavell Edwards Stadium by Utah State will do that

BeardedSpock

10/10/18 7:50pm

Yep. I wanted Kalani fired before and after Wisky

Coogar2

10/10/18 8:02pm

To be fair I only want him fired at the end of the season

BYU313

10/10/18 10:08pm

I think Jay Hill is likely the best option

BYU Fan

10/12/18 11:08am

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad