Do it. I could point out many plays where he made the right move.

Report problem with this ad

Oct 11, 2018
11:20:23am

canofpicante Walk-on

There are too many variables for you to start talking about “proof”.

Report problem with this ad

canofpicante

Bio page: canofpicante
Joined: Oct 14, 2011
Last login: Jan 25, 2024
Total posts: 4,645 (8 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Proof that it's a Tanner problem, not a scheme problem or WR problem.

Rise Against

10/10/18 1:38pm

I don’t disagree with your point, but not many QBs scrambling right are going to

Mike Honcho

10/10/18 1:42pm

Why was he rolling right?

Coop

10/10/18 1:43pm

This. We have all watched Tanner Ball the last 4 years. Panics and rolls right.

Flippy

10/10/18 1:44pm

Exactly. THERE WAS NO PRESSURE. Bad habit he hasn't broken. He struggles in the pocket.

Turnpike Lane

10/10/18 1:44pm

<< Deleted >>

Turnpike Lane

10/10/18 1:45pm

Easier for a right handed quarterback to roll right and throw?

fldnstrm

10/10/18 2:09pm

vs. planting and throwing? Nope.

dYrtbYkerYder

10/10/18 4:52pm

Obviously. The question was asked why he rolled right?

fldnstrm

10/10/18 10:49pm

TM has the bad habit of rolling right (or left) unnecessarily. That is my point.

dYrtbYkerYder

10/11/18 10:10am

Yes, his consistent panicked run to the right hurts his ability to pass.

SandYFan

10/10/18 1:43pm

I don't believe that was a designed roll out play. That was his own doing.

Rise Against

10/10/18 1:45pm

He wasn’t scrambling for any good reason. There was no pressure

Denesheo

10/10/18 2:24pm

Love made the same play for a TD in the game. He has a little less experience

Ash

10/10/18 7:12pm

You misspelled evidence

Coop

10/10/18 1:42pm

"panicked" too

displacedute

10/10/18 4:51pm

You could do this on most plays. Tanner struggles to see guys open all the time. Has for 2 seasons now.

Turnpike Lane

10/10/18 1:44pm

<< Deleted >>

Unibro

10/10/18 1:54pm

Disagree on pass to Katoa.

Brigham

10/10/18 1:45pm

RE: Disagree on pass to Katoa.

Turnpike Lane

10/10/18 1:45pm

That is the better question. Doesn’t look like pressure forced it.

Brigham

10/10/18 1:46pm

You do it when you have absolutely no confidence in your line OR you have

SandYFan

10/10/18 1:47pm

I disagree it looks like there is pressure by the USU DE on the right side,

fldnstrm

10/10/18 2:12pm

Watch the video posted below. He is so wide open. The defender actually

byubyu

10/10/18 1:53pm

If you want to watch the video yourself, here you go:

Rise Against

10/10/18 1:47pm

He never looks left - not a glance - and he was wide open from the first

calbearcoug

10/10/18 9:08pm

I don't think anyone on this board could play better than Tanner

cambo

10/10/18 1:47pm

Because they're not better qbs means nobody on the board could hit that pass?

Goliath

10/10/18 1:52pm

I'm not sure . . . Does John Beck post here? Ryan Hancock?

2FarGone

10/10/18 2:12pm

Riley Nelson?

TailgateU

10/11/18 9:59am

For all of the Tanner apologists, how do you explain this kind of play

Rise Against

10/10/18 1:50pm

The real question you should be asking is:

Ham

10/10/18 2:26pm

We'll see come Saturday if they still do let him play. I for one think that game

Rise Against

10/10/18 2:49pm

Man, that first screenshot is sad, especially on a 3rd and 6th.

westsidecoug

10/10/18 1:50pm

This. It's crazy that they lined up like that on defense.

tcherrin

10/10/18 2:33pm

What's crazy is the teams that HAVEN'T lined up like this. UW and USU

Mr. Scoobs

10/10/18 2:35pm

I bet Wisconsin wants a do-over.

Rise Against

10/10/18 2:50pm

I think McNeese St wants a do over

LaserCoug

10/11/18 8:44am

Depends on what the linebackers actually did post snap?

BlueTooth

10/10/18 4:31pm

This comes back to he CB debate.....does Tanner have "It"

WJCougar

10/10/18 1:51pm

<< Deleted >>

East1999

10/10/18 1:53pm

Tanner's biggest problem is bailing from the pocket too early and also holding

Dangerous

10/10/18 1:59pm

+ throwing motion. + no progressions.

calbearcoug

10/10/18 9:09pm

One play is your PROOF? Obviously you’re no scientist.

canofpicante

10/10/18 2:06pm

My thoughts exactly. While I am not a Tanner apologist, one play is lousy

Nagurski

10/10/18 2:15pm

Then how about his 114.5 PER in 2018 and 110.8 in 2017?

Turnpike Lane

10/10/18 2:25pm

I am not saying I disagree with the idea that Tanner should be done. However,

Nagurski

10/10/18 2:38pm

It's one play that is meant to illustrate the overarching issues being discussed

Byron McNertney

10/10/18 2:47pm

Yeah, but that play is a 3rd down blitz that most teams would do against most QB

viper

10/10/18 3:37pm

Is it unreasonable for me to expect a 5th year senior to recognize that blitz,

Rise Against

10/10/18 3:59pm

It was obvious that it was a blitz, and the sideline called in a new play, I

viper

10/10/18 4:41pm

That doesn’t PROVE it’s Tanners problem either.

canofpicante

10/11/18 12:19pm

I said I could go back to the film and point out many other plays that were

Rise Against

10/10/18 2:43pm

Do it. I could point out many plays where he made the right move.

canofpicante

10/11/18 11:20am

Sure but I could point out plays he did make

I'mBatman

10/10/18 2:07pm

I don't think anyone is claiming Tanner never makes the right read or never

dilbert

10/10/18 2:15pm

We would have lost anyway, but you cannot just swat away those 2 TO's of his.

Ash

10/10/18 10:50pm

Your "proof" that Tanner is the problem is because they blitzed on a 3rd down?

viper

10/10/18 2:08pm

I think the point is most of the time teams can totally stack the box on us

westsidecoug

10/10/18 2:16pm

Sad that our WR's can't get open with a man to man coverage? What should Tanner

viper

10/10/18 2:21pm

The QB is as much to blame as anyone else for a poor passing game and allowing

westsidecoug

10/10/18 2:26pm

we had WR wide open all game long

Littlerich

10/10/18 2:29pm

In College Football as goes your QB so goes your team.

RockyBalboa

10/10/18 2:10pm

Pretty much all football.

IronPotato

10/10/18 8:12pm

For one, Tanner is sooooo much better in the shotgun. Just putting him under

777

10/10/18 2:15pm

I don't know why Detmer and Grimes never figured out that he's a shotgun QB.

IronPotato

10/10/18 10:22pm

Then our coaches must be awful. Because they're the ones that picked him.

Ham

10/10/18 2:22pm

And they’ll be the ones to sit him really soon too.

Turnpike Lane

10/10/18 2:31pm

Thats why you are not a coach/analyst. Katoa was the 5th read on that play.

Cougz19

10/10/18 2:53pm

I never said he should have scrambled to the left. He shouldn't have left the

Rise Against

10/10/18 3:01pm

There was no pocket watch the play again

Cougz19

10/10/18 3:02pm

No pocket? What do you call this?

Rise Against

10/10/18 3:11pm

I've watched that play a dozen times now and Tanner takes off running without

Rise Against

10/10/18 3:13pm

the ball should be in the air already. its late before he even starts to rollout

molodyets

10/10/18 3:31pm

come on look at the receivers do they look ready to catch a ball?

Cougz19

10/10/18 4:13pm

I look at this and think, “Man, that’s where Taysom was so valuable.”

Duke Silver

10/10/18 6:17pm

4 receivers to the right running routes

Cougz19

10/10/18 3:03pm

Another glaring problem for anyone who wants to submit themselves to

Rise Against

10/10/18 3:03pm

He always under thrown deep. He just had 6'6" dawgs who wanted to catch the ball

Cougz19

10/10/18 3:12pm

I think he throws far enough, just 0.5 or more seconds late.

Y2010

10/10/18 4:35pm

You don’t get it. Tanner is lacking but HC is worse

Coogar2

10/10/18 3:31pm

Tanner is the victim here. #believethevictim

Borg

10/10/18 3:33pm

Paying fans are the victim. Believe us!

Goliath

10/10/18 3:35pm

Remember when Collie was wide open pre-snap but Tanner didn't see it..*eye roll*

PokeBowl

10/10/18 4:00pm

1 play where he looks to have pressure coming from the side you want him to

cougaman

10/10/18 4:16pm

Hey, in case you have forgotten, Mangum was an elite 11 co-champion with Jameis

Bluegoogles

10/10/18 4:38pm

2011 was so 7 years ago - He was just a boy back then having fun w/o pressure

PokeBowl

10/10/18 4:54pm

Cougarboard is where that tidbit won't ever die, as we were constantly

Bluegoogles

10/11/18 7:43am

Shame on you! TM is really really really really good guy.

Gerald-DeGroot

10/10/18 4:49pm

Agreed. I guess there are a couple.

Posting on CougarBoard