Interesting. Did you feel the same way about Mangum and Heaps?

Report problem with this ad

Jun 11, 2019
10:53:41am

displacedute All-American

Report problem with this ad

displacedute

Bio page: displacedute
Joined: May 30, 2005
Last login: Apr 18, 2024
Total posts: 10,937 (29 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Athlon ranks Wilson the 46th-best QB in the country

Gustav

6/11/19 9:54am

That's a fair evaluation now

newbie

6/11/19 9:55am

#1 in the state of Utah, imo.

Heinz57

6/11/19 9:59am

And #1 in our hearts

pink22

6/11/19 10:04am

Athlon disagrees. By about 30 slots.

ironman1315

6/11/19 10:05am

They would be wrong

cougarmanguy

6/11/19 10:06am

Wilson's SOS was harder?

displacedute

6/11/19 10:20am

Thought we were discussing love. But Wilson is way better than Huntley

cougarmanguy

6/11/19 10:29am

Athlon disagrees

displacedute

6/11/19 10:30am

And they would be wrong

cougarmanguy

6/11/19 1:10pm

I understand that one could make an argument that he is better, especially

Jdoc

6/11/19 12:23pm

Yes, he already had better numbers as a freshmen

cougarmanguy

6/11/19 1:11pm

The comparison is where they are now. You say Wilson is "way better". I don't

Jdoc

6/11/19 1:27pm

Alright - fair response. Where are they now? Wilson seems a slightly better by the numbers qb. As to

cougarmanguy

6/11/19 1:37pm

I agree with that. As a Utah fan, if I had my choice right now I would take

Jdoc

6/11/19 1:42pm

For 2019 I'd much rather have Huntley.

displacedute

6/11/19 4:22pm

I hope he can stay healthy, but I doubt he will.

Jdoc

6/11/19 4:25pm

So I get that...

CoachSpeak

6/11/19 4:35pm

You're biased (and so am I), but I think Huntley's very dynamic.

displacedute

6/11/19 5:10pm

RE: You're biased (and so am I), but I think Huntley's very dynamic.

BrobaFett

6/11/19 5:19pm

Against a terrible usc team. Wilson is better

cougarmanguy

6/11/19 5:33pm

RE: Against a terrible usc team. Wilson is better

BrobaFett

6/11/19 5:47pm

Stats prove my point. Data is in favor of wilson

cougarmanguy

6/11/19 6:14pm

Not it isn't.

displacedute

6/11/19 10:54pm

RE: So I get that...

BrobaFett

6/11/19 5:18pm

You apparently haven’t read all of my posts...

CoachSpeak

6/11/19 6:44pm

Oh and no coach would rank Huntley “most desirable”...

CoachSpeak

6/11/19 6:48pm

Wait, Utah has a top 3 Pac 12 QB? Who?

Lip Gallagher

6/11/19 8:42pm

RE: Alright - fair response. Where are they now? Wilson seems a slightly better

BrobaFett

6/11/19 5:48pm

Sure

cougarmanguy

6/11/19 6:57pm

I mean if you want to compare apples and cucumbers it’s fine but Huntley

ironman1315

6/11/19 7:28pm

Right. Because he wasn’t good enough.

cougarmanguy

6/11/19 7:38pm

If mangum was a good qb instead of abjectly terrible, would Wilson have seen

ironman1315

6/11/19 8:31pm

yes

cougarmanguy

6/11/19 10:19pm

Then why did your coaches have a bad QB in Mangum starting the year?

ironman1315

6/11/19 10:25pm

True, but isn’t that a mark against him?

CoachSpeak

6/11/19 7:46pm

I definitely wouldn't trade him for Huntley

cougarnw

6/11/19 10:20am

Nor would I...

CoachSpeak

6/11/19 10:23am

What if you only got them for this year?

displacedute

6/11/19 10:24am

Wilson. By far

cougarmanguy

6/11/19 10:30am

Interesting. Did you feel the same way about Mangum and Heaps?

displacedute

6/11/19 10:53am

cougarmanguy

6/11/19 10:54am

Wilson...

CoachSpeak

6/11/19 10:34am

Huntley is a much more dynamic player at this point

LifelongAP

6/11/19 10:14pm

RE: They would be wrong

Jacob4thejazz

6/11/19 11:10pm

You missed the part, where I said IMO.... 🙂

Heinz57

6/11/19 8:24pm

I think Love and Huntley would rate higher now just based on

Dangerous

6/11/19 10:08am

RE: #1 in the state of Utah, imo.

Solomon Levi

6/11/19 10:21am

Darn right....got to stick up with my boy Zach

Heinz57

6/11/19 10:26am

I get it!

Solomon Levi

6/11/19 10:30am

#3 in the state in Athlon's opinion

displacedute

6/11/19 10:22am

And you are a Ute, so that doesn't count 🙂

Heinz57

6/11/19 10:25am

RE: And you are a Ute, so that doesn't count 🙂

displacedute

6/11/19 10:54am

First game will be fun

Heinz57

6/11/19 11:10am

And they are probably correct based off of what each has done so far...

CoachSpeak

6/11/19 10:31am

PFF disagrees on the whole accuracy thing.

ironman1315

6/11/19 10:53am

They obviously didn't watch him play live much...

CoachSpeak

6/11/19 11:02am

They watched every passing down. (Or so they claim)

ironman1315

6/11/19 11:11am

Meh...

CoachSpeak

6/11/19 11:16am

Scratch

6/11/19 11:43am

He's the Marriott Bonvoy of Utah QBs

Epileptic Beagle

6/11/19 10:22am

I think thats a good start, but I think he'll be top 25 by the end of the year.

AlphaCoug

6/11/19 10:00am

If he is that would bode well for BYU's season...

CoachSpeak

6/11/19 11:11am

Seems about right. CB has an over-inflated view of him because of his

Dangerous

6/11/19 10:07am

Why are you only posting his yards thrown? In those games (and all season up

Ash

6/11/19 1:19pm

Didn't BYU run more in the bowl game than they passed?

CoachSpeak

6/11/19 1:25pm

Correct. Which is why we were down 10-7 at the half in a game where we

Ash

6/11/19 1:33pm

I can't see any justification to rank him any higher at this point...

CoachSpeak

6/11/19 10:10am

Given how their list is created, I think it would be easy or at least arguable

Lip Gallagher

6/11/19 1:28pm

I also saw some rankings there I thought were to high...

CoachSpeak

6/11/19 1:40pm

Top 50 recruit! Awesome!

BYUALWAYSNUM1

6/11/19 10:11am

Wilson hasn't proven himself...

Yergensen

6/11/19 10:35am

I disagree. I think he proved that he has what it takes to be a big time QB.

DadBod

6/11/19 2:39pm

Trevor Lawrence, Clemson should be #1 and Tyler Huntley #16 is a joke!

blackshirts

6/11/19 2:15pm

Yeah I don't get the love for Huntley... 2:1 TD to INT ratio and 0 great wins.

DadBod

6/11/19 2:50pm

Tagovailoa's numbers were significantly better.

ochobeeguy

6/11/19 3:25pm

TL didn't start the season as the starter. Really, all you have to do is watch

blackshirts

6/11/19 6:35pm

Ranking of projected starting QBs for our scheduled opponents

CougarThug

6/11/19 2:22pm

Love is #12

displacedute

6/11/19 4:27pm

If coaches played the best QB earlier in season he would be higher

Y4LYFE

6/11/19 2:35pm

Bryce Perkins (UVA) #21

run26

6/11/19 3:33pm

How many sophomores ahead of him on the list? Too hard to figure out

Idahofallsblue

6/11/19 10:28pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad