I don’t neccessarily disagree that Hudley has a slight edge now, but only because he is a senior and Wilson is a Sophmore coming off an arm injury. Wilson throws a better ball and by seasons end will be a better qb.
As to the original post, it’s got too much byu positions. The ol might be even at best; most byu fans have our ol overrated. They might be experienced, but they melted down against good defenses last year and still have a lot to prove. And Yewtah lost a couple guys on its OL, but has some experience and huge recruits coming in as replacements.