Ty’Son was in bounds.

Sign up, and you can make all message times appear in your timezone. Sign up

Report problem with this ad

Sep 4, 2019
7:17:31pm

the_byu_flash Playmaker

Ty’Son was in bounds.

Should have been 1st and goal instead of 3rd down.

Alright #BYU fans, I know Ty'Son was called OOB on this run. But on closer review, it looks like he may have been in. Would it help if they weren't wearing white cleats? For reference, on the next play, BYU brought in the wildcat package and the ball was mishandled for a loss. pic.twitter.com/AiPOPmvGk2
— Zak Hicken (@zakhicken) September 5, 2019

https://twitter.com/zakhicken/status/1169401919338512386

Report problem with this ad

the_byu_flash

Previous username: MWKV3
Bio page: the_byu_flash
Joined: Dec 9, 2015
Last login: Apr 23, 2024
Total posts: 11,812 (67 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Ty’Son was in bounds.

the_byu_flash

9/4/19 7:17pm

We have to get neutral refs

Borg

9/4/19 7:21pm

1) that's not why it was missed. It's just a tough call. 2) NOONE gets

fattycoug

9/4/19 9:43pm

Visiting team supplies refs. BYU supplied them last year.

CallingDingo

9/4/19 11:10pm

These little misses are really starting to add up.

8man

9/4/19 7:21pm

P12 officiating

mudpupper

9/4/19 7:25pm

No kidding.

Benfica1

9/5/19 4:28pm

Why wouldn’t that have been reviewed?

BW84

9/4/19 7:23pm

Exactly. Don’t whistle the play dead. Look at review if it’s obviously so close.

Betruewhiteandblue

9/4/19 10:13pm

He was out. His foot lands inbounds but looks like it slides just into the chalk.

No touching

9/4/19 7:26pm

I think you are right

thebruce

9/4/19 7:29pm

It didn’t look like it (to me) on the slow mo

More of a Jazz Fan

9/4/19 7:39pm

Me neither. It didn't look like his foot slid at all.

BYUJoJo

9/4/19 9:02pm

Looks like there is always some green between foot and line.

Benfica1

9/5/19 4:29pm

That's incorrect.

9/4/19 7:41pm

I'm not sure who is arguing his foot slid inward. In any case, it's close, and I don't think you can fault the ref.

No touching

9/4/19 7:46pm

Read that backwards. But he didn't go out either way. And no, you definitely

9/4/19 7:50pm

I see green between his cleat and the sideline. Maybe only half an inch but its there...

icecougar

9/4/19 8:07pm

Nope. Inbounds.

YSMACK

9/4/19 9:01pm

This video intentionally doesn't show the other angles used in replays.

9/4/19 9:32pm

Yup the other view showed he clearly stepped out

rggee

9/4/19 9:55pm

The other angles are likely wrong due to the angle

puntersarepeople

9/5/19 7:19am

Interesting that we all looked at the slo mo, and the thumbs up and down are split. Close.

No touching

9/5/19 7:37am

He's in. There is space between the line and foot.

Benfica1

9/5/19 8:00am

there are 100's of these incidents during every game. You could easily find holds, blocks in backs, targeting etc by

BlueFrog

9/4/19 7:28pm

True. The difference is that this call stopped a play from happening. It's one

SUAVO

9/4/19 7:43pm

blocks in backs...you mean like in Covey's 40 yd punt return?

icecougar

9/4/19 8:02pm

Yes, but I mean there's 100s of those a game right?

Grit for Brains

9/4/19 8:22pm

yep. if not more. every play there is a penalty somewhere that is going uncalled

BlueFrog

9/4/19 9:59pm

yep. for sure that was one that was missed

BlueFrog

9/4/19 9:58pm

This one was at a critical time, but I agree and it was about as close as

WizeGuise

9/4/19 8:16pm

This is why dissecting all these calls after the game is pretty and childish

Machiavelli

9/4/19 8:51pm

But you can't find incorrect in bounds and out of bounds calls. And when you ...

COACHdrn

9/4/19 9:03pm

Inbounds.

Cougarclaw

9/4/19 7:31pm

Don't think that does anything to change 2 pick 6's or giving up 8 yards per

Skeptical Optimist

9/4/19 7:32pm

Did he say that it did?

SUAVO

9/4/19 7:48pm

It does a ton. Sports is about momentum,if that play is called right BYU has 1st

palangi

9/4/19 9:33pm

We lost. The refs made some bad calls. Time to move on

DieHarder

9/4/19 7:32pm

nothing to move on to until we play the next game and get something new to...

icecougar

9/4/19 8:01pm

I can hardly wait

DieHarder

9/4/19 8:28pm

Hopefully it’s a win

puntersarepeople

9/4/19 9:03pm

Ty'Son should have gotten the ball on 3rd down either way... That is close

cougaman

9/4/19 7:35pm

Watch AFR they show this play from multiple angles, and it never was raised.

Sport sci

9/4/19 10:08pm

It looks like #20 had him stopped anyway

franklyvulgar

9/4/19 7:36pm

After the first

jaredm

9/4/19 7:39pm

Dang, we always lose to Utah unfairly. Every. time.

D.T. Survivor

9/4/19 9:03pm

The proof is in the video tapes. LOTS of bad calls when we play Utah.

BleedCougarBlue2

9/4/19 10:42pm

Is that not a play that Sitake could have had reviewed?

Greg Kite's 'stache

9/4/19 9:07pm

We've unfortunately been saying this too many times the past few years.

COACHdrn

9/4/19 9:12pm

First coaches don't challenge for reviews. Second, out of bounds and the whistle

palangi

9/4/19 9:37pm

Coaches can challenge in college football. They get one, if they win it, they

fredgarvin

9/4/19 10:03pm

Didn’t the ESPN guys say the replay booth wasn’t PAC-12?

CallingDingo

9/4/19 9:12pm

That’s on the replay crew. Ridiculous that wasn’t looked at and overturned

jkccoug

9/4/19 9:36pm

Nothing to overturn, it was a running play not a catch, so whistle blows play

palangi

9/4/19 9:39pm

They showed another angle during the play and his toes were clearly out.

ochobeeguy

9/4/19 9:38pm

What better angle is there than straight down the sideline from in front of...

BleedCougarBlue2

9/4/19 10:58pm

The one that zoomed in on the shoe and showed it on the line.

ochobeeguy

9/5/19 9:47am

We didn't lose because of the refs but every single questionable call went

Ash

9/4/19 9:58pm

Moss’ facemask was a joke.

CallingDingo

9/4/19 11:09pm

His stiff arm where he pulled the defenders facemask down? That was an easy call

palangi

9/4/19 11:45pm

But it was the first facemask called against a RB in the history of football.

ochobeeguy

9/5/19 9:52am

The rule requires twisting or pulling. A shove does not qualify

CallingDingo

9/5/19 4:14pm

Hence the word PULL in the post you just replied to.

cougaman

9/5/19 4:32pm

No pull. None whatsoever

CallingDingo

9/5/19 4:38pm

I see the defenders head jerk forward after he pulls his arm away. I can see why

cougaman

9/5/19 4:47pm

Actually, it was the correct call. He grabbed and pulled.

Benfica1

9/5/19 5:02pm

"In" bounds. End of discussion. Shafted again by the refs. If we had....

BleedCougarBlue2

9/4/19 10:57pm

The game is over, btw

qom

9/5/19 5:41am

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad