My Account
Sign up, and you'll be able to vote in polls.
Sign up
Report problem with this ad
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Sep 15, 2019
4:52
:09
pm
zerigke
Starter
Just watched the 3rd down Pittman catch out of bounds review
I think we got extremely lucky. I think his toe was down. I also think that gets overturned 8/10 times.
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Report problem with this ad
zerigke
Previous username
l8kr4life_
New username
Zerigke Ally Zerigke
Bio page
zerigke
Joined
Feb 6, 2008
Last login
Dec 5, 2023
Total posts
0 (0 FO)
Report problem with this ad
Messages
Author
Time
Just watched the 3rd down Pittman catch out of bounds review
zerigke
9/15/19 4:52pm
Too Zapruder to overturn
Indy Coug
9/15/19 4:55pm
And USC got extremely lucky on the long Pittman TD catch.
AD4
9/15/19 4:59pm
Easily could have been offensive PI.
Jeffacka
9/15/19 5:11pm
Was called for almost the exact thing later in the game.
ochobeeguy
9/15/19 7:24pm
Maybe not offensive PI - but definitely went out of bounds on his own!!!
farsurfer
9/15/19 9:54pm
I think it might have been a catch. I think it is overturned 2/10.
CosmoK
9/15/19 4:59pm
I think you are correct. It may have been a makeup call.
Backcountry
9/15/19 5:04pm
My thoughts exactly
towerman
9/15/19 5:14pm
If you just think then they got it right
Turnpike Lane
9/15/19 5:06pm
It really is that simple. I don't know why this is so hard.
Lip Gallagher
9/15/19 5:21pm
And that’s rules of the game. Every team deals with it...
Refugee
9/15/19 9:56pm
It doesn't matter if you think. You have to know.
Lip Gallagher
9/15/19 5:20pm
That’s why I wish the refs only had 60 seconds per review
KingDave
9/15/19 5:24pm
I bet you are a high level exec at some super successful corporation or
slowhiteguy
9/15/19 5:25pm
There should be a shot clock on video reviews. If you can’t see in 30 seconds, move on
YIsForBrigham
9/15/19 5:47pm
I think 4 out of 5 times
johnnybyu
9/15/19 5:22pm
Thank Chad Bunn
Beggar
9/15/19 5:42pm
Not even close to conclusive evidence that his toe touched. Easy "Call stands".
Ironhide
9/15/19 5:55pm
I think the question was control vs. timing of toe touch.
CosmoK
9/15/19 6:40pm
There is no definitive evidence of a toe touch inbounds
Captain Stubing
9/15/19 10:19pm
Watched it several times. I didn't see anything conclusive.
Dr T-bone
9/15/19 6:59pm
I don't think his touched the ground. It may hav skimmed the top of some grass, but it never touched down.
SpiffCoug
9/15/19 6:59pm
Is skimming the top of the grass enough?
kC Cougar
9/15/19 7:17pm
Probably. But w/ BYU goggles on it's not down if it only touches the top of the grass.
SpiffCoug
9/15/19 7:19pm
His left foot touched and propelled him out, but before he had control.
ochobeeguy
9/15/19 7:25pm
This is what I think. The left foot was floating not down.
kiyoshige
9/15/19 8:27pm
But you can't tell if he was still gathering the ball.
ochobeeguy
9/15/19 7:23pm
I think that gets overturned 0/10 times if the booth is doing their job.
Mojave
9/15/19 7:35pm
The point about extremely lucky is fair. Could have been called a catch and then indisputable goes the other way.
WaybackCougar
9/15/19 8:09pm
Exactly.
Refugee
9/15/19 10:28pm
Key word. "Think". Different from "for sure". That's why call stood.
Coug Dude
9/15/19 9:00pm
RE: Just watched the 3rd down Pittman catch out of bounds review
cmarrio
9/15/19 9:34pm
Report problem with this ad
Posting on CougarBoard
In order to post, you will need to either
sign up
or
log in
.
Report problem with this ad