2013 - #3 Jordan Lynch - NIU
2007 - #3 Colt Brennan - Hawaii
1994 - #3 Steve McNair - Alcorn State
1992 - #2 Marshall Faulk - SDSU
1991 - #3 Ty Detmer - BYU
1990 - #1 Ty Detmer - BYU
1989 - #1 Andre Ware - Houston
1987 - #3 Gordie Lockbaum - Holy Cross
1985 - #3 Robbie Bosco - BYU
1984 - #3 Robbie Bosco - BYU
1983 - #2 Steve Young - BYU
1981 - #3 Jim McMahon - BYU
1979 - #3 Marc Wilson - BYU
1971 - #2 Ed Marinaro - Cornell