In that case, I don't think we can celebrate him until he does something.

Sign up, and you can customize which countdowns you see. Sign up

Report problem with this ad

Jan 16, 2020
8:45:41am

runnincoug All-American

In that case, I don't think we can celebrate him until he does something.

I agree BYU will have to go after under-recruited but diamond in the rough guys. But we can't call it a win until they actually help us ... win. Otherwise it's just guesswork.

At least with players with p5 offers we have a bit more confidence because other schools also thought they were studs. With under-recruited guys, we have to wait for them to show it on the field before we can celebrate, IMO.

Report problem with this ad

runnincoug

Bio page: runnincoug
Joined: May 26, 2011
Last login: Apr 24, 2024
Total posts: 33,276 (2,514 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Sitake recruits with multiple P5 offers expected to be on the 2020 roster

donnerstag

1/16/20 6:34am

No RBs, and only 1 WR and DB on the list. Not coincidentally, these are

SafetyFirst

1/16/20 7:22am

Those have been historically the positions hardest to recruit to BYU

donnerstag

1/16/20 7:31am

Which is why going to a defense that emphasizes dbs over lbs seems dumb

runnincoug

1/16/20 8:03am

Byu emphasizes that? LBs have been a giant part of the defense.

1/16/20 9:02am

Rumors are they are moving to a 4-2-5 defense.

runnincoug

1/16/20 9:13am

That was some random CBer. They're not taking LBs off the field next year.

1/16/20 9:20am

All our flash LB are basically big safeties already

22jrob22

1/16/20 9:26am

Which doesn't mean BYU is "moving" to a 4-2-5.

1/16/20 9:45am

Totally agree

22jrob22

1/16/20 10:34am

I like that they've been going after athletic undervalued players like Udo

palangi

1/16/20 8:11am

who? he hasn't played right?

runnincoug

1/16/20 8:39am

A little, he made the 2 deep right away then had some lingering injury

palangi

1/16/20 8:42am

In that case, I don't think we can celebrate him until he does something.

runnincoug

1/16/20 8:45am

I like that approach, I didn't say it's already paid off. Chasing highly

palangi

1/16/20 8:53am

I have no idea if BYU will move to a 4-2-5 defense, but I would suspect

Doogal McCougar

1/16/20 12:22pm

How many players on the team didn’t

1/16/20 8:02am

There are at least a couple players where that was the case

donnerstag

1/16/20 8:09am

There are several types of offers...

1/16/20 3:34pm

Hopefully we can land Bodie Schoonover. I think we will.

andrewg3

1/16/20 8:23am

If we have to take 1, do we take Romney or Schoonover?

Doogal McCougar

1/16/20 2:02pm

Do we have to take 1? Why not both?

andrewg3

1/16/20 3:43pm

RE: Sitake recruits with multiple P5 offers expected to be on the 2020 roster

bluenowandforever

1/16/20 8:51am

Complain to 247 and Rivals if you have an issue with the reported offers

donnerstag

1/16/20 12:33pm

RE: Complain to 247 and Rivals if you have an issue with the reported offers

bluenowandforever

1/17/20 8:27pm

That’s the issue. There is no proof....

1/16/20 4:13pm

I know we have 1923580235289 LB'ers in the pipeline but Tausinga

RockyBalboa

1/16/20 9:09am

Tausinga is really really good. I am shocked he was underrecruited.

Tangotongo

1/16/20 11:37am

Exicted about Hanshaw, Livai, and another year of health for Tofa

TPcoug

1/16/20 9:12am

Shouldn't Uriah be on this list? He at least had Stanford chasing him.

al3124

1/16/20 9:17am

He was even committed to Stanford IIRC.

Genghis Spreads

1/16/20 9:54am

Looks like it, yes. Stanford, Wisconsin, Wazzu, Colorado, and more

andrewg3

1/16/20 9:56am

I excluded the Bronco signed recruits

donnerstag

1/16/20 10:15am

Shouldn't you exclude Troy Warner then? Was he not a Bronco recruit?

andrewg3

1/16/20 2:04pm

Signed with Sitake

donnerstag

1/16/20 2:23pm

12/20 are Polynesian. 11/20 offense. 9/20 defense. 18/20 LDS.

ag4cougs

1/16/20 10:35am

Except all but two freshmen have been a part of the team

coldcoug

1/16/20 11:20am

Only two were upperclassmen

donnerstag

1/16/20 11:31am

How does this number (20) compared with prior years? Can’t tell if this is good

ray ray

1/16/20 11:27am

Someone I know for a fact would have had P5 offers is Bruce Garrett.

Tangotongo

1/16/20 11:39am

And yet the 247 Composite ratings for the last 4 years

CallingDingo

1/16/20 12:32pm

Players having P5 offers means they are P5 talents.....

TPcoug

1/16/20 12:36pm

BYU has P5 talent, just not as deep

Doogal McCougar

1/16/20 12:37pm

maybe not but this depth beats the pants off the bronco era

Tangotongo

1/16/20 1:07pm

At least Bronco won. I'm not sure your argument holds water.

coolblue

1/16/20 5:16pm

Sure it does I said nothing about coaching, this thread is about recruiting

Tangotongo

1/16/20 10:45pm

RE: BYU has P5 talent, just not as deep

bluenowandforever

1/17/20 8:29pm

Chaz Ah You filling up the second line! Nice! He reminds me so much of Van Noy

CT98

1/16/20 2:48pm

Every player at Utah had a P5 offer. . .

CosmoK

1/16/20 2:52pm

This is a list of players with "multiple P5 offers"

donnerstag

1/16/20 3:04pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad