Sign up, and you'll be able to vote in polls. Sign up
Jan 17, 2020
11:13:42pm
cougarfan84 All-American
If I had to choose a conference for BYU and the only rule was no P5, I would
take the AAC (with UConn leaving as already announced) and drop Tulane and ECU.

That would leave a 9 team conference with:

Houston
SMU
Tulsa
Memphis
UCF
USF
Cincinnati
Navy
Temple

(swap Navy for Wichita St. in basketball).

Add Boise St., BYU, and San Diego St. in all sports, Air Force and Army in football, and Gonzaga and St. Mary's in basketball.

That would leave a pretty strong conference for both basketball and football.

Here is the final rankings in the Massey rankings comparison for football this year (Top 65):

#13 Memphis
#20 Navy
#21 Cincinnati
#22 Air Force
#23 Boise St.
#25 UCF
#31 SMU
#39 San Diego St.
#57 Temple
#58 BYU

(10 of 14 being in the top half of FBS).

And in current Pomeroy basketball rankings (Top 100):

#5 Gonzaga
#12 San Diego St.
#27 BYU
#29 Houston
#36 Wichita St.
#39 St. Mary's
#40 Memphis
#48 Cincinnati
#82 SMU
#84 Temple

(10 of 14 teams being in top 100 with 8 teams being potential NCAA tourney teams).

That would at the very least give the AAC essentially a guarantee of the "G5" auto bid every year in football, and would force them to be considered a major power conference in basketball.
cougarfan84
Bio page
cougarfan84
Joined
Apr 3, 2003
Last login
Apr 24, 2024
Total posts
19,105 (2,476 FO)
Related Threads Topic: Any chance we can team up with Boise and join a conference? (the_byu_flash, Jan 17, 2020 at 6:04pm)

Children:
You missed the entire point of the post. We stay independent for when there is (ColonelMustard, Jan 18, 2020 at 12:55pm)

Messages
Author
Time

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.