I don't care if a kid is good at tackling people. I don't think we should be lenient on him because he can do sports.
If my daughter (a BYU student) got pregnant out of wedlock she would be kicked out of school. A convicted DUI should at least have the same punishment.
He can clean himself up, work his way back into school.
but it shouldn't ever be "well, he is a 4* player, sooo.... "