Almost no differences

Feb 17, 2020
7:35:14pm

Medute All-American

Both are suburbia areas with close by amenities, church stuff, activities, excellent schools, etc.

Seriously. One is just closer to all the business action, so the price is much higher

Report problem with this ad

Medute

Bio page: Medute
Joined: Jun 29, 2010
Last login: Apr 18, 2024
Total posts: 17,461 (1,107 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Two choices of home purchase vs commute - which do you choose?

Medute

2/17/20 6:47pm

commute. my family has always chosen commute

Cougarclaw

2/17/20 6:48pm

45 min isn't awful - especially if only 3 days a week.

Skeeziks

2/17/20 6:49pm

3 days per week isn't too bad

Gustav

2/17/20 6:50pm

If it was 5 day a week I’d say 5 min commute.

Noni Fruit

2/17/20 6:50pm

45 each way? And is it 45 with the potential to be hours if traffic is bad?

byubyu

2/17/20 6:52pm

45 is the average. It’s about 35 to work, 55 home

Medute

2/17/20 7:02pm

I would do closer. You're never going to regret living close to work.

byubyu

2/17/20 7:13pm

I have had nearly this exact scenario.

dtownCoug

2/17/20 7:55pm

acougfan

2/17/20 6:54pm

Closer house. But I hate commuting.

chrisoc13

2/17/20 6:55pm

It must be some house if it’s the upper limit. Since your commuting 3 days a wk

SouthernBlueBlood

2/17/20 6:56pm

Traffic is always consistently bad here. Reliably bad

Medute

2/17/20 7:03pm

Probably B

Run-DMT

2/17/20 6:58pm

Commute. Audiobooks and podcasts make commutes enjoyable

Slim

2/17/20 6:59pm

I don’t mind the 35 minutes to work. But 55-60 home is painful

Medute

2/17/20 7:04pm

An hour drive home after a long day at work would kill me.

JohnnyComeLately

2/17/20 7:42pm

Normally would vote shorter commute, but only 3 days a week, vote better house.

BYUtka

2/17/20 7:01pm

What’s best for kids. That’s what I would chose

Idahofallsblue

2/17/20 7:03pm

I’d go swank and 5 min drive and wouldn’t even think twice about it.

OceanMang

2/17/20 7:08pm

Doc Buff

2/17/20 7:10pm

You can fix a house with the extra time you have. I vote a.

Florwood

2/17/20 7:12pm

Thanks for asking. Im in same boat in VA.

sah22

2/17/20 7:12pm

I will never have a commute over 10 minutes again if I can get away with it

BYUFootballisBack

2/17/20 7:19pm

Better house, wife will be in that more than you and be much happier.

Blue for Life

2/17/20 7:22pm

I just had to make a similar choice. Went with A.

Y05

2/17/20 7:23pm

Commute = I loudly sing along with my favorite songs of the 80s time.

svenot

2/17/20 7:23pm

Important clarification: What is the distance from each house to the golf club?

Plato

2/17/20 7:23pm

I’m not good enough nor do I have the time to make this question matter

Medute

2/17/20 7:33pm

The right answer is where your wife wants to live.

Qhall

2/17/20 7:24pm

Yep, I said as much to her the other night

Medute

2/17/20 7:32pm

Is there a difference between the two re: church experience for kids?

unctoothman

2/17/20 7:25pm

Very similar areas. High quality people. Can’t go wrong with either

Medute

2/17/20 7:32pm

I have a 5 minute commute. I wish it were longer.

IGlowInTheDark

2/17/20 7:32pm

You enjoy commuting or you hate being at home?

OceanMang

2/17/20 7:35pm

I don’t mind 10-20 minutes gives you a little time to think and decompress from

cougarfann888

2/17/20 7:45pm

have to consider school district, distance to church or other places you'll go often

byujag

2/17/20 7:33pm

Almost no differences

Medute

2/17/20 7:35pm

if all else is really equal then I would take the better house

byujag

2/17/20 7:39pm

RE: if all else is really equal then I would take the better house

85fan

2/17/20 8:36pm

How long do plan on being in this house?

StantonMac

2/17/20 7:35pm

Hopefully we aren’t moving again for a long time

Medute

2/17/20 7:36pm

Is the renovation potential enough to turn it into a house you love?

MarkWatney

2/17/20 7:49pm

^^ding ding ding

d-coug

2/17/20 8:01pm

Yeah, but it would take a long time and a lot of work

Medute

2/17/20 8:07pm

I live in northern OK and work in Atlanta, GA. Takes me 4 hrs to get to work...

BleedCougarBlue2

2/17/20 7:38pm

Also, what are the odds that you stay at 3 days for the rest of your career?

OceanMang

2/17/20 7:40pm

No more promotions in my line of work

Medute

2/17/20 8:14pm

Exactly. Every minute adds up.

byubyu

2/17/20 7:40pm

Sounds like you need to move to Atlanta

Coug98

2/17/20 7:41pm

Bob Vance

2/17/20 7:40pm

Sounds like you might want to put in an offer on both houses.

Y05

2/17/20 7:42pm

I chose close commute and not as nice house. I was commuting 2.5 hours total

WhirleyPop

2/17/20 7:45pm

I enjoy a little commute to be able to unwind from the work day

GeraldGarner

2/17/20 7:48pm

Do you have kids? Are the schools/wards comparable? We’re looking at a similar dilemma sometime in the next few years

Mike Honcho

2/17/20 7:54pm

I hate commuting but would still choose B. You’ll spend more time in your house

Odysseus

2/17/20 8:01pm

I have an hour and 10 minute commute, but only work in office three days a week. Totally worth it to me to live in the

scootsy

2/17/20 8:05pm

Closer house. You know your wife is going to remodel the nice home anyway.

jvquarterback

2/17/20 8:16pm

45-60 minute commute for me each way. I love the time to decompress, listen to podcasts or books away

TEXAS

2/17/20 8:38pm

We’re moving this week to a place 2 hours from my job

cougfanz

2/17/20 9:03pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad