Neither pcr or viral culture will prove immunity. Needs to be serologic test

Apr 3, 2020
11:06:40pm

Run-DMT All-American

for IgG antibodies to COVID-19.

This is not about diagnosis of active infection, but screening the population to identify the percentage of people who have already had the virus and cleared it.

This message has been modified

Originally posted on Apr 3, 2020 at 11:06:40pm

Message modified by Run-DMT on Apr 3, 2020 at 11:09:57pm

Report problem with this ad

Run-DMT

Bio page: Run-DMT
Joined: Sep 16, 2006
Last login: Apr 22, 2024
Total posts: 6,358 (62 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Good news: Random testing shows several in Italy had covid who thought they

BYUCougarsFan

4/3/20 8:20pm

Very interesting

ABCoug

4/3/20 8:21pm

Way to undersell! Several = 66%.

Plato

4/3/20 8:22pm

Not really underselling. Sure it is 2/3 but still a total of 40 people

Y05

4/3/20 9:45pm

I've never heard 40 referred to as several. 2 score!

Plato

4/3/20 9:59pm

I have always thought it is widespread, started in Jan

johnnycarson

4/3/20 8:24pm

They want it both ways. It's super contagious, but somehow just hung around for

Harbinger

4/3/20 8:26pm

That's wild. If that's the case, herd immunity is there.

ebv

4/3/20 8:25pm

I didn’t think antibody tests were working yet.

8-track

4/3/20 8:27pm

This would be my concern

webster242

4/3/20 8:39pm

FDA authorized test.

ORCoug

4/3/20 9:06pm

Terrible decision making based on terrible information.

Coach's Dad

4/3/20 8:31pm

Agreed. The answer has always been to put all resources we can into testing.

johnnybyu

4/3/20 8:35pm

The solution to false positives is more testing, not less

webster242

4/3/20 8:40pm

I am in agreement. The more testing you do the better you get at it, the lower

johnnybyu

4/3/20 8:54pm

Yep from the beginning the govt should have made it very clear they would pay

Coach's Dad

4/3/20 8:44pm

Yep should have been a wartime effort in getting testing stations on every

johnnybyu

4/3/20 9:00pm

Could have saved 1.5 trillion.

Coach's Dad

4/3/20 9:01pm

Totally agree. People were saying the economics didn't work because testing

johnnybyu

4/3/20 9:07pm

If true this is a game changer. We really need to test everyone so we have

johnnybyu

4/3/20 8:34pm

IMO, Utah is going to test really high in serology testing.

Lance71

4/3/20 9:11pm

Why? Lot of Chinese tourists in Utah?

byu1

4/3/20 9:38pm

We need to do the serology testing in mass numbers

Run-DMT

4/3/20 8:42pm

Great News: Utah is now doing randomized testing

akmewg

4/3/20 8:44pm

The test they got from China were unreliable and faulty

travelcoug

4/3/20 9:12pm

Wow

byu1

4/3/20 9:21pm

Not to be a Debbie downer, but antibody testing has a much higher probability of

doctorcoug

4/3/20 9:24pm

I think most people have false sense of doom

ABCoug

4/3/20 9:35pm

Lol. I think people should take a deep breath. After seeing our plans, I think

doctorcoug

4/3/20 9:47pm

That's not a high confidence interval?

Plato

4/3/20 10:01pm

It's pretty good, but it is compared to something that we have no comparison

doctorcoug

4/3/20 10:05pm

Neither pcr or viral culture will prove immunity. Needs to be serologic test

Run-DMT

4/3/20 11:06pm

It’s the same reason I see so many people with “Lyme Disease”

Nakedbootleg

4/3/20 10:25pm

This is precisely the point. I had a patient with measles symptoms. Antibody for

doctorcoug

4/3/20 10:57pm

Circulating IgG antibody levels to a virus is a way to confirm immunity.

Run-DMT

4/3/20 11:12pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad