None of your QB's would crack the two deep at the U. And you state they would start or back up on 2/3 of P5 teams.
Did 2/3 of these 3 QB's recruiting offers come from P5? Combined did the 3 of them have more than 3 P5 offers? Combined do they have more than 2 P5 wins?
What exactly are the qualifications you're using beside your own fandom for making this claim?