Zach should be third string. He flat out loses games. Hall has most upside.

May 22, 2020
11:07:30pm

Blue2thebone All-American

The other guy is the least likely to lose a game and he is just steady. Don’t remember his name but definitely safer option that the Wilson.

Report problem with this ad

Blue2thebone

Bio page: Blue2thebone
Joined: Oct 5, 2012
Last login: Apr 23, 2024
Total posts: 11,022 (182 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Sophomore Seasons - John Beck vs. Zach Wilson

Cdun101

5/22/20 8:33pm

That's a nice comparison...Thanks

DOC

5/22/20 8:36pm

Correct

I'mBatman

5/22/20 8:39pm

Well said.

Cdun101

5/22/20 8:45pm

Thank you for this post. Seriously people, we should learn our lesson from the

bigbossbyu

5/22/20 9:11pm

Ridiculous claim, what's your basis?

Yergensen

5/22/20 9:59pm

Well one had an offer from the U . . .

puntersarepeople

5/22/20 10:21pm

So what? Was it a tenuous offer? Was it to play QB?

Yergensen

5/22/20 10:46pm

Offer to play QB. They definitely wanted him

puntersarepeople

5/22/20 10:55pm

Should also be noted that beck played against 3 teams that all finished the season undefeated and in the top 10

TEXAS

5/23/20 10:35am

Loving Zach's completion %. Didn’t realize it was that high.

Manti

5/22/20 8:46pm

I didn’t either. Pretty impressive.

Cdun101

5/22/20 8:47pm

Also impressed that all games were > 100 qbr.

Adwight

5/22/20 8:55pm

If Zach can improve his decision-making, he could make big strides this year.

m0resn0w

5/22/20 9:00pm

Couldn’t agree more

Cdun101

5/22/20 9:03pm

Not sure if I or the announcers are more excited to make some sweet sweet

bigbossbyu

5/22/20 9:26pm

Nah I’m hoping it’s more like John Beck

puntersarepeople

5/22/20 10:23pm

Beck is my favorite BYU Qb ever. Started to really follow BYU during his JR yr.

bigbossbyu

5/23/20 2:45am

It’s no guarantee

puntersarepeople

5/23/20 9:50am

I think comparing him to the other QBs on the roster is more fruitful, including

Incentivize

5/22/20 10:10pm

RE: I think comparing him to the other QBs on the roster is more fruitful,

Cdun101

5/23/20 10:02am

I don't think so. Too many variables, including sample size.

Lip Gallagher

5/23/20 10:23am

Zach should be third string. He flat out loses games. Hall has most upside.

Blue2thebone

5/22/20 11:07pm

You're insane

Lip Gallagher

5/23/20 10:01am

My guess, if you took a players poll. ZW would be the unanimous choice.

Thrill

5/23/20 12:23pm

I doubt that

puntersarepeople

5/23/20 12:32pm

I know several personally and that is what they have told me.

Thrill

5/23/20 1:16pm

I doubt it would be unanimous, not that a good chunk would like ZW

puntersarepeople

5/23/20 1:21pm

Don’t doubt it. It’s nothing personal, if someone steps up, then that dude

Thrill

5/23/20 1:49pm

Hall has the type of talent and ability that may come by a program only every

Blue2thebone

5/23/20 10:57pm

Based on 1.5 games

puntersarepeople

5/23/20 11:09pm

Why is John Beck the right comparable? Other candidates would be John Walsh,

The Chelsea Dagger

5/24/20 2:46am

Started as true freshman

puntersarepeople

5/24/20 11:32am

What makes Max Hall a comparison?

Lip Gallagher

5/24/20 1:01pm

Yeah Max had a RS year to learn under Beck

puntersarepeople

5/24/20 1:25pm

The reason I don’t like Beck as a comp is he never really looked good as a frosh

The Chelsea Dagger

5/24/20 10:37pm

Those guys weren’t injured all offseason though

puntersarepeople

5/25/20 8:17am

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad