My guess, if you took a players poll. ZW would be the unanimous choice.

Sign up, and you'll be able to vote in polls. Sign up

Report problem with this ad

May 23, 2020
12:23:07pm

Thrill All-American

My guess, if you took a players poll. ZW would be the unanimous choice.

This is not saying anything about the other guys who will get their turns, but ZW can be special.

Report problem with this ad

Thrill

Bio page: Thrill
Joined: Dec 1, 2001
Last login: Apr 24, 2024
Total posts: 56,780 (1,165 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Sophomore Seasons - John Beck vs. Zach Wilson

Cdun101

5/22/20 8:33pm

That's a nice comparison...Thanks

DOC

5/22/20 8:36pm

Correct

I'mBatman

5/22/20 8:39pm

Well said.

Cdun101

5/22/20 8:45pm

Thank you for this post. Seriously people, we should learn our lesson from the

bigbossbyu

5/22/20 9:11pm

Ridiculous claim, what's your basis?

Yergensen

5/22/20 9:59pm

Well one had an offer from the U . . .

puntersarepeople

5/22/20 10:21pm

So what? Was it a tenuous offer? Was it to play QB?

Yergensen

5/22/20 10:46pm

Offer to play QB. They definitely wanted him

puntersarepeople

5/22/20 10:55pm

Should also be noted that beck played against 3 teams that all finished the season undefeated and in the top 10

TEXAS

5/23/20 10:35am

Loving Zach's completion %. Didn’t realize it was that high.

Manti

5/22/20 8:46pm

I didn’t either. Pretty impressive.

Cdun101

5/22/20 8:47pm

Also impressed that all games were > 100 qbr.

Adwight

5/22/20 8:55pm

If Zach can improve his decision-making, he could make big strides this year.

m0resn0w

5/22/20 9:00pm

Couldn’t agree more

Cdun101

5/22/20 9:03pm

Not sure if I or the announcers are more excited to make some sweet sweet

bigbossbyu

5/22/20 9:26pm

Nah I’m hoping it’s more like John Beck

puntersarepeople

5/22/20 10:23pm

Beck is my favorite BYU Qb ever. Started to really follow BYU during his JR yr.

bigbossbyu

5/23/20 2:45am

It’s no guarantee

puntersarepeople

5/23/20 9:50am

I think comparing him to the other QBs on the roster is more fruitful, including

Incentivize

5/22/20 10:10pm

RE: I think comparing him to the other QBs on the roster is more fruitful,

Cdun101

5/23/20 10:02am

I don't think so. Too many variables, including sample size.

5/23/20 10:23am

Zach should be third string. He flat out loses games. Hall has most upside.

Blue2thebone

5/22/20 11:07pm

You're insane

5/23/20 10:01am

My guess, if you took a players poll. ZW would be the unanimous choice.

Thrill

5/23/20 12:23pm

I doubt that

puntersarepeople

5/23/20 12:32pm

I know several personally and that is what they have told me.

Thrill

5/23/20 1:16pm

I doubt it would be unanimous, not that a good chunk would like ZW

puntersarepeople

5/23/20 1:21pm

Don’t doubt it. It’s nothing personal, if someone steps up, then that dude

Thrill

5/23/20 1:49pm

Hall has the type of talent and ability that may come by a program only every

Blue2thebone

5/23/20 10:57pm

Based on 1.5 games

puntersarepeople

5/23/20 11:09pm

Why is John Beck the right comparable? Other candidates would be John Walsh,

The Chelsea Dagger

5/24/20 2:46am

Started as true freshman

puntersarepeople

5/24/20 11:32am

What makes Max Hall a comparison?

5/24/20 1:01pm

Yeah Max had a RS year to learn under Beck

puntersarepeople

5/24/20 1:25pm

The reason I don’t like Beck as a comp is he never really looked good as a frosh

The Chelsea Dagger

5/24/20 10:37pm

Those guys weren’t injured all offseason though

puntersarepeople

5/25/20 8:17am

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad