I agree, but the “indisputable” standard is inconsistently followed. It is what

Sign up, and you'll be able to vote in polls. Sign up

Report problem with this ad

Nov 28, 2020
4:33:53am

RealityCheck All-American

I agree, but the “indisputable” standard is inconsistently followed. It is what

Whatever the replay booth thought the call should be. There are hundreds of overturns that are totally disputable. That standard is simply empty and meaningless and doubly so in the PAC.

It is my understanding that the original purpose of review was to only overturn very obvious bad calls, not close calls.

Report problem with this ad

RealityCheck

Bio page: RealityCheck
Joined: Jan 8, 2002
Last login: Mar 15, 2024
Total posts: 3,797 (16 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Here’s the Oregon State touchdown that was called short, even after the review.

RdF3 All-American

11/27/20 9:57pm

And the real shame is the QB got hurt on the next play that never should have

rivercitycoug

11/27/20 9:58pm

Was he hurt or just cramping up?

O Gaucho

11/27/20 10:01pm

His legs were ripped apart into a near split. Looked pretty painful

LosAlcoug

11/27/20 10:04pm

That's the angle I was talking about.

brj8

11/27/20 9:59pm

There was no way to overturn the play based on the camera shots they showed on

11/27/20 9:59pm

What he just posted shows the ball on top of the line. What more do you need?

brj8

11/27/20 10:00pm

That isn’t indisputable I’m sorry. I 100% think it is in but the way the rule

11/27/20 10:09pm

That wasn’t the only angle. There was one angle down the line. It was a TD.

rainorsnow

11/27/20 10:13pm

Okay. So both announcers and the replay official said you can’t see the ball

11/27/20 10:16pm

Because it’s impossible for the ball to be below his butt.

rainorsnow

11/27/20 10:18pm

Look I get it but you can’t actually see the ball so it is technically

11/27/20 10:26pm

Replay gives fans a false sense of security to get the right call. Refs have

Preppy

11/27/20 11:38pm

I agree, but the “indisputable” standard is inconsistently followed. It is what

11/28/20 4:33am

Um...indisputable touchdown

Bostonblue

11/27/20 10:02pm

logic as in knowing simple Geometry that if he is leaning backwards, and the

cougaman

11/27/20 10:07pm

I’ve learned not to argue with people this obtuse.

antiyewt

11/27/20 10:09pm

Wow. Calling me obtuse for saying it isn’t indisputable is pretty weak on your

11/27/20 10:12pm

Sure there was. His butt was the first thing down on the goal line. He was facing backwards

BYU '80

11/27/20 10:46pm

Yeah I'd say that's indisputably a TD

JuicyJam

11/27/20 10:00pm

New P12 rule: The ball will be placed where your feet are when the play is

11/27/20 10:00pm

His waist came down basically on the line, he was holding the ball up at his

cougaman

11/27/20 10:02pm

There's no way that's not a TD... P12 refs.

Cougar8Duck

11/27/20 10:03pm

But, it ate clock, and that was also good at that point.

BYUtka

11/27/20 10:06pm

RE: But, it ate clock, and that was also good at that point.

newbee

11/27/20 10:22pm

It was a difference of 7 seconds, but Oregon did use 2 timeouts.

cougaman

11/27/20 10:26pm

"But they can't see the ball." Entire torso was across the line. Unless the ball

Preppy

11/27/20 10:48pm

That's why you NEVER want PAC 12 Refs. ALWAYS give advantage to the team that will make them the most $$$

Coug Dude

11/27/20 11:03pm

Another day in the life of the PAC12.

11/27/20 11:10pm

One angle shows the ball high on his chest. Another angle shows his torso over the goal line. That is

HarlemCoug

11/27/20 11:21pm

His Fanny pack is on the goal line and the ball is above that. That angle shows

akmewg

11/28/20 1:00am

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad